News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How aware are you about building decentralised so... by nonameiguess on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @02:34PM (#27752539)
This doesn't get rid of middlemen, though. Blockchain is not truly peer to peer. It relies on blockchain nodes, which you can run yourself, but mostly people don't do that, and it isn't free to do. The reason users of the blockchain don't currently have to pay anything to use it is that owners of blockchain nodes earn money by holding coins that appreciate relative to their local legal currency at a sufficiently fast rate that they don't need to charge their users.

That doesn't seem like a permanently sustainable business model. Coin values can't keep shooting up forever, and at some point blockchain node owners are going to need to either shut down or directly charge blockchain users, and then you're back to the same situation as normal payment processors.

Re:Ask HN: How aware are you about building decentralised so... by billytetrud on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @05:43PM (#27754725)
> Blockchain is not truly peer to peer.

"Blockchain" isnt a single thing. Bitcoin is definitely peer to peer. Most cryptocurrencies are operated in a peer to peer way.

> It relies on blockchain nodes, which you can run yourself, but mostly people don't do that

Most people not doing it is irrelevant. They can if they want. They can get rid of more middle men if they want. Even using custodial cryptocurrency services get rid of some layers of middlemen and so is still a win.

> and it isn't free to do

Yes it is. There is no substantial cost in running a bitcoin node for example.

> The reason users of the blockchain

There is no such thing as "the blockchain"

> the reason.. users .. don't currently have to pay anything to use ["the blockchain"] is that owners of blockchain nodes earn money by holding coins that appreciate relative to their local legal currency at a sufficiently fast rate that they don't need to charge their users.

You're wrong on many many levels, as I told you in my other comment to you. Please stop trying to explain things that you clearly don't understand.