News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by dang on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @01:39PM (#27751799)
"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something."

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by trasz on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:58AM (#27758184)
Sorry, I’ve assumed that my point is clear, given the quote: Aquinas’ work is based on assumptions which perhaps made sense back then, but now are obviously wrong, rendering his conclusions worthless (apart from their historical value, of course).
Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by danielam on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @01:02PM (#27751270)
> ... is, technically, BS. And pretty much all of Aquinas follows this pattern. Which was very highly regarded back then, but now we know better.

You seem confident in that assertion. Care to elaborate, preferably with examples/arguments?

N.b., it's not the first time I've heard such a claim so boldly stated. Typically, dismissive attitudes toward Thomas are rooted in widespread misunderstanding about what he actually argued and on what basis. Feser, for example, recalls how he had held a caricaturish view of some of the most famous arguments Thomas put forth because those caricatures are what are often taught to students of philosophy nowadays, largely because the caricatures have become part of academic received wisdom, not necessarily because of some ill intent.

None of this is to say that Thomas is infallible, just that he is a great teacher. Arguments that rely on the science of his day, for example, may require revision, but his philosophical synthesis, for example, is, at the VERY least, very defensible.

Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by slumdev on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @01:12PM (#27751429)
The clarity of St. Thomas is incomprehensible to anyone raised in postmodernism and not educated in philosophy.
Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by huetius on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @02:22PM (#27752374)
I’m not sure that’s true. There is a certain strand in postmodernist/critical thought that, by consistently seeking to unmask power, recovers the perennial, “religious” questions. Some examples might include Horkheimer’s later works, Simone Weil, or Habermas, who famously had an encounter with Pope Benedict XVI (then, Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger) that caused him to reevaluate a lot of his views towards religious thought. I think Aquinas is also pretty accessible to the dedicated novice. Maybe you mean positivist instead of postmodernist? In that case, yeah, I’d agree.
Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by slumdev on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @02:29PM (#27752471)
Postmodernist suppositions regarding power and ideology include an implicit assumption that absolute truth doesn't exist.

That used to be called relativism.

It's ad hominem at scale -- an attack on the institutions that produced centuries of good work rather than an honest confrontation of the work itself.

Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by dang on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @03:04PM (#27752905)
Please don't take HN threads into generic ideological tangents. The more generic they get, the more repetitive and tedious they are, and then they inevitably turn nasty.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by slumdev on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @01:07PM (#27751340)
> Which was very highly regarded back then, but now we know better.

Aquinas is still highly regarded. Virtually every philosophy department in the Western world still teaches him.

Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by Cybotron5000 on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @04:37PM (#27753907)
Bertrand Russell on Thomas Aquinas: “There is little of the true philosophic spirit in Aquinas. He does not, like the Platonic Socrates, set out to follow wherever the argument may lead. He is not engaged in an enquiry, the result of which it is impossible to know in advance. Before he begins to philosophize, he already knows the truth; it is declared in the Catholic faith. If he can find apparently rational arguments for some parts of the faith, so much the better; if he cannot, he need only fall back on revelation. The finding of arguments for a conclusion given in advance is not philosophy, but special pleading.” [History of Western Philosophy p. 453]
Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by cbfrench on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @05:20PM (#27754427)
Of course, Anthony Kenny countered Russell’s assertion by humorously noting, “ It is extraordinary that that accusation should be made by Russell, who in the book Principia Mathematica takes hundreds of pages to prove that two and two make four, which is something he had believed all his life” (Aquinas on Mind, 11).

Russell also misunderstands much of Thomas’s project in this quotation. To my knowledge, Thomas never claimed to be doing philosophy (at least not according to the modern understanding of it); most of his work is theology that happens to have philosophical implications. But as Thomas notes in the opening articles of the Summa Theologica, theology as a scientia takes divine revelation as its first principles and makes rational deductions on the basis of that deposit of revelation. Importantly, however, it pursues its ends using particularly theological methods and criteria, some of which overlap with philosophical methods and criteria, while others do not.

But the starting point of theology is Anselm’s “Credo ut intelligam,” not Descartes’s Cogito. To imagine that theology is just some poorly-conducted version of philosophy is fundamentally a category error.

Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by Cybotron5000 on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @06:26PM (#27755175)
So theology need not make any rational sense whatsoever? It is more an affirmation/fiction/opinion that represents the authors’ own intuitions about divine matters, or perhaps proceeds from a survey/study of previous hierology/sacred texts? Is an experience of personal revelation therefore necessary to study the subject? You believe a man must believe in a (presumably exclusively Christian?) God, as defined in canonical scriptures, as interpreted by the Catholic church, to study or rationalise about theology? Augustine defined ‘theologia’ as: "…reasoning or discussion concerning the Deity..." - but he got the ‘rationem’ bit wrong? Aristotle must also have been a misguided old fuddy-duddy when he stated that there were three aspects of theoretical philosophy: mathematics, physics and theology - or rather he didn’t mean theology as you define it, but instead something more akin to metaphysics? Thomas Aquinas defines theology as: ‘…what is taught by God, teaches of God and leads to God’ - this seems much closer to what you suggest? A person must first believe, and then an understanding, or more knowledge, of the nature of a god, that you already believe in, will more likely accrue to the initiate after appropriate study, but only given that prior belief? Would you agree with Thomas Paine: “The study of theology, as it stands in Christian churches, is the study of nothing; it is founded on nothing; it rests on no principles; it proceeds by no authorities; it has no data; it can demonstrate nothing; and it admits of no conclusion. Not anything can be studied as a science, without our being in possession of the principles upon which it is founded; and as this is the case with Christian theology, it is therefore the study of nothing.” …or Protagoras: "Concerning the gods I cannot know either that they exist or that they do not exist, or what form they might have, for there is much to prevent one's knowing: the obscurity of the subject and the shortness of man's life." …understand that might be a bit heavy duty/tough ask for a HN comment - but I am genuinely interested if you can point me to useful passages/sources/help me understand Aquinas’/your ideas better…
Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by Cybotron5000 on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @09:04PM (#27756235)
“…Hence nothing prevents those things which may be learned from the philosophical disciplines, so far as they can be known by the light of natural reason, from being considered by another science according as they are known by the light of divine revelation. Hence theology included in sacred doctrine differs in kind from that theology which is part of philosophy…”
Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by igouy on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @02:08PM (#27764065)
> Thomas never claimed to be doing philosophy

?

"The Summa Contra Gentiles is meant as a philosophical work"

Anthony Kenny (Aquinas on Mind, 13)

http://people.exeter.ac.uk/sp344/Aquinas%20on%20Mind.pdf

Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by trasz on Wednesday July 07, 2021 @03:03AM (#27758221)
Theology is to philosophy what alchemy is to chemistry. Sure, it’s not technically a poorly-conducted version of the other, that would be a category error, but you can’t really ignore their relationship either.
Re:Thomas Aquinas' works with English and original Latin pre... by mensetmanusman on Tuesday July 06, 2021 @01:39PM (#27751803)
Before immediately jumping to BS, it is sometimes illuminating to consider whether the words today may have changed meaning after centuries :)