Re:Ask HN: Strategy for password reset email vs URL to reset...
by halayli on Sunday July 17, 2011 @11:32PM
(#2775007)
So if I know a user's email I can lock their account by just triggering a reset password.
Re:Ask HN: Strategy for password reset email vs URL to reset...
by ra on Monday July 18, 2011 @01:10AM
(#2775193)
Yeah brute force lockout is a destructive attack.
A better lock-out approach is to disable logins for a period of time (say 1 minute)... i.e. as someone said above, you don't want to destroy the old password in case the reset was requested by someone else.
1. replace their current hash with "LOCKED", plus some random noise.
2. generate a random string, and store the hash in a "forcedResetToken" field for the user.
3. email them a URL, part of which is the token.
4. when the link is activated, I look up the user account by the hash of the token, force them to choose a new pw, and remove the forcedResetToken.
That's the approach I take in my Wicket Quickstarter project (http://armhold.com/store).
Based on other comments I'm seeing, I'm now planning to also add an expiration of the token (say 24 hours or something).