It's the disrespect of tracking agencies and web developers that killed the concept.
The only workable solution to that problem in practice is legal/political: legislation and sufficient regulatory abilities to effect compliance (i.e. GDPR/PECR and the like). In the end, the US stuck with permit-all-by-default and largely don't care, the EU/UK went deny-tracking-by-default with penalties to back it up.
The reality is that this proposal will fail for much the same reasons: either you have an opt-in mindset from personal beliefs or legal requirements, in which case the global off-switch is worthless to you; or you're pro-tracking, in which case the incentives are to ignore the switch. Or you're Debian etc. and you remove the tracking code outright...
Accepting DNT would imply that the tech community was wrong on this one, and that will never happen.
So it's dead without a name change.