News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Quora is in trouble by cletus on Sunday July 17, 2011 @09:31AM (#2773276)
You can count me as one of the long-term Quora detractors. To me, it's a good example of the "bubble effect". Everyone in the Valley thinks its huge because everyone in the Valley uses it.

No one outside the Valley does (figuratively speaking).

It's a thin social layer on what's just a Q&A site not that different to Yahoo Answers, which I guess is fine but I just don't see it going mainstream.

As an aside, I've always said--and I maintain--that I don't see Stackoverflow/StackExchange going mainstream either.

Ultimately I see the end for both companies being a Google or Facebook buyout in the $X00,000,000 range, which I think says more about the overall market than it does their inherent value.

EDIT: let me add regarding SO/SE that I think the SO model works great for programmers but my point--which I didn't put very well--was that I don't see that same tagging/voting/self-organizing model necessarily translating that well to other verticals. I guess time will tell.

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by macavity23 on Sunday July 17, 2011 @09:41AM (#2773291)
Although I agree that Stack[Overflow|Exchange] will never been a mainstream site, I think there's an important difference in that SO is very useful to the community that it does support.

They've really nailed the technical question 'problem' to the point that my day-to-day job would be measurably harder without it, and so as the poster says I can easily imagine paying for added-value features there.

Quora, not so much. Although I really doubt the solution is to add more eye-candy to the page design. Sheesh, web designers. ;-)

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by codingthebeach on Sunday July 17, 2011 @09:46AM (#2773294)
From the article:

"The site is visually bland: there’s barely any color or images, and you won’t find any effect fancier than rounded corners."

Somebody please save us from the attack of web design. If I see another gradient rounded flashing Javascript-enabled button for gradient rounded flashing Javascript-enabled buttons' sake, I'm gonna hurl, Wayne's World style.

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by dasil003 on Sunday July 17, 2011 @12:10PM (#2773534)
Flashing buttons? Sounds like you're frequenting some dark alleys. Make sure your anti-virus is up-to-date.
Re:Why Quora is in trouble by mgkimsal on Sunday July 17, 2011 @01:06PM (#2773653)
agreed. look at craigslist - about as unsexy a design as you could imagine, but it solves real problems for people, and they use it constantly. quora - not so much, and fancier buttons and UI won't really change that.
Re:Why Quora is in trouble by jamesteow on Sunday July 17, 2011 @01:22PM (#2773682)
His point wasn't about making it more fancy but rather, less sterile. Even Craigslist has more character.
Re:Why Quora is in trouble by sgdesign on Sunday July 17, 2011 @10:44AM (#2773376)
Well, to be fair there was a certain kind of logic behind my "shiny buttons will save Quora" argument:

1) Pivot 2) Redesign 3) Existing members come for the redesign and stay for the new Quora, thus giving the new strategy a chance.

Although you could say that when all you have is Photoshop, every site looks like it needs to be redesigned… ;)

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by cruise02 on Sunday July 17, 2011 @12:28PM (#2773566)
I think Stack Exchange has a much better chance of going mainstream, but by going through the side entrance, not through the front door. Some of the SE sites will fail (a handful already have), but others will be successful in their niche. By keeping the focus small in each community, they're making much more useful sites. I think a lot of people will end up using SE sites without really knowing or caring that they're at an SE site.

Disclosure: As a Stack Overflow moderator, I'm quite biased.

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by ams6110 on Sunday July 17, 2011 @01:55PM (#2773766)
No one outside the Valley [uses Quora]

I'll validate that: I've barely heard of it. I've never visited, and it never seems to turn up in Google or DDG searches.

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by jaredmck on Sunday July 17, 2011 @05:24PM (#2774235)
It doesn't show up in searches because for a long time the whole site was noindexed. Think they changed this, but considering the whole site is designed much like an SEO spamfest (tags, ridiculous hierarchy), it didn't make a whole lot of sense.
Re:Why Quora is in trouble by jdp23 on Sunday July 17, 2011 @01:40PM (#2773730)
I'm also a long-term Quora skeptic -- and have been documenting the reasons why in the comments at http://bit.ly/imitates#comments for the last six months. Agreed about the likely outcome; hard to know about the valuation.

And agreed with the other commenters that StackExchange/StackOverflow is in a very different situation. It's hard to know whether or not they'll get to "mainstream"; but they don't necessarily have to in order to be a very successful company. And they've got a huge advantage of several topics where they are one of the best resources on the web -- and an much larger active community than Quora.

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by biot on Sunday July 17, 2011 @04:27PM (#2774112)
Re:Why Quora is in trouble by ilamont on Sunday July 17, 2011 @02:10PM (#2773808)
"Ultimately I see the end for both companies being a Google or Facebook buyout in the $X00,000,000 range, which I think says more about the overall market than it does their inherent value."

Can you explain how a site like Quora would be worth at least $100,000,000 to Google, Facebook, or anyone else?

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by jdp23 on Sunday July 17, 2011 @02:42PM (#2773874)
Aardvark's acquisition by Google for $50M about 18 months, back when the market wasn't as bubblicious as it is now, is one comparable. http://redmonk.com/sogrady/2010/02/12/aardvark-google/ looks at why that valuation arguably made sense. Aardvark had $6M invested, Quora's got $11M.

Like I said in my other comment, not sure what valuation makes sense, so I'm not convinced it'll be in the X00,000,000 range... but it's not impossible.

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by adityakothadiya on Sunday July 17, 2011 @02:07PM (#2773801)
"Everyone in the Valley thinks its huge because everyone in the Valley uses it."

My techie friends from Silicon Valley also don't use Quora. So don't worry, not everyone in Valley uses it. I think very few % of Valley users are using it.

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by tzs on Sunday July 17, 2011 @06:57PM (#2774438)
math.stackexchange.com and mathoverflow.net are working well, from what I can see, so the model works in at least one area outside of programming.

Mathoverflow has become a place where serious mathematicians go to discuss research level mathematics, and some of the world's top mathematicians ask and answer questions there (including at least a couple Field's medalists).

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by clb22 on Monday July 18, 2011 @03:10AM (#2775401)
FYI, I'm very engaged with Quora, and I live in Chile http://www.quora.com/Carlos-Leiva-Burotto and through Quora I made networking with a guy who works on Mauritian Island.. that's in the front of Madagascar!!!! Not even through Twitter, Facebook, Digg, Flickr, etc I engaged with someone from that place!!

So Quora is definitely a worldwide tool and the active members are not only people from SV.

You should definitely open your mind to not see only the things that you want to see.

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by jaredmck on Sunday July 17, 2011 @05:21PM (#2774225)
Isn't stack overflow in the top 100 sites in terms of traffic? While it might not be mainstream, it's already huge.
Re:Why Quora is in trouble by nl on Sunday July 17, 2011 @08:37PM (#2774659)
You are basing that on Alexa? Alexa will always over-report sites like Stackoverflow, because lots of SEO people (who use the Alexa toolbar) use it.

Google trends gives a better view. Here is is related to other sites that (according to Alexa) have similar traffic: http://trends.google.com/websites?q=stackoverflow.com%2C+dou...

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by edanm on Sunday July 17, 2011 @11:13AM (#2773417)
Regarding Stack Exchange, I understand (and agree) with your view that there are lots of verticals it won't work in. But do you think programming is the only vertical in which it can work?

My view is, the model will work well for some places, badly for others, and that's perfectly fine - for the places it works well, it works really well. For the others, other solutions will be thought up.

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by revorad on Monday July 18, 2011 @05:20AM (#2775633)
How does a 9-figure exit prediction make you a Quora detractor?
Re:Why Quora is in trouble by Hisoka on Sunday July 17, 2011 @10:14AM (#2773329)
StackOverflow, because of its subject matter will never be mainstream, but I it's immensely popular among those in the programming community, and that's a pretty huge market.
Re:Why Quora is in trouble by quanticle on Sunday July 17, 2011 @12:14PM (#2773540)
I don't think StackOverflow is really trying to be a general, mainstream Q&A site, largely because there is no mainstream when it comes to Q&A sites. When you go to one of these sites, you don't want your question to be answered by a generalist, you want a specialist with domain knowledge to answer your question.

Looking at it that way, the StackExchange model makes sense. Make a number of very specialized communities that experts can congregate in. Make a points system that rewards experts for their time and effort. Finally, invest in making the site friendly to search engines, so that non-experts can find the experts and ask questions of them.

Re:Why Quora is in trouble by cruise02 on Sunday July 17, 2011 @12:37PM (#2773578)
Right, Stack Overflow itself can never be mainstream by definition, but cletus is talking about the (slightly) larger Stack Exchange network of Q&A sites that SO is a part of.