News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Social Entrepreneurship Ideas? by zmmz on Sunday July 17, 2011 @03:47AM (#2772791)
I am looking forward to the blog post. Please post it on HN when it comes around.

Until I read to the third paragraph of the snippet, I was thinking "this is just another polling website", but the innovation that is proposed could result in some interesting results.

After reading the snippet, I was excited to go visit the site, expecting some thoughtful discussion on current affairs and politics. I was pretty disappointed with the activity on the site.

I understand that currently the site consists of the core functionality, but you should make that clear. If I was just a standard visitor I would have no incentive to come back in a few months when the app actually has some meaning.

A final note: when I vote in elections, my vote is anonymous and private. On hyperarchy I can see who voted on a topic, in 'real life' this information is not available and I believe that many people would not want it to be known what they are voting on.

Re:Social Entrepreneurship Ideas? by nathansobo on Sunday July 17, 2011 @07:24AM (#2773087)
Hey, thanks for checking it out. I'm the founder of the site. I myself have had some qualms about the low-brow nature of some of the discussions. I think as the site's interface evolves it's becoming easier to discuss deeper ideas. Here's an interesting discussion on the federal budget: https://hyperarchy.com/questions/394. But at first it was just my friends talking about their favorite kind of nut. Not world-changing material to be sure.

Was it the lack of delegation, or just the non-political / deep nature of many discussions that was most disappointing? What would we need to change to make it more interesting to you?

As far as anonymity, making votes public is a controversial choice but it's important to us. We want to heavily favor transparency, and it makes for a more social experience. Looking at other people's votes is actually the number 1 thing people do on Hyperarchy.

Thanks for your feedback!