News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by Daniel_Newby on Saturday July 16, 2011 @04:12PM (#2771650)
It's hard to believe claims of a "genetic underclass."

There have been several large studies of identical twins separated at birth. For a given twin, the strongest correlate of IQ is the other twin's IQ. Likewise, the non-identical but biologically-related siblings do have moderately correlated IQs. However, there is barely any correlation between a twin and their adoptive parents or siblings. This suggests that genetics and prenatal environment determine most of IQ.

There is also strong evidence from gene sequencing that genetics directly affects IQ. Genes that affect sphingolipids, chemicals important in the brain, are known to affect IQ. A variation in the SNAP-25 gene has been found to increase intelligence by an average of 3 IQ points.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by cdavid on Saturday July 16, 2011 @07:21PM (#2772094)
Identical twins studies are often flawed, because the environment difference between twins is far from random for obvious reasons. For example, in one of the (often used) minesota studies about IQ and twins, the average IQ of the father was 120, whereas the state average was 105 (see http://psycnet.apa.org/journals/bul/125/4/392/).

And while it has become a cliche, it is still true that correlation is not causation: coming up with correlation is easy, but solid scientific works need to prove that the correlation is not spurious. Most studies don't (this is sadly not specific to discussions about IQ, and is a plague of many studies in too many areas - good statistics are hard).

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by tokenadult on Sunday July 17, 2011 @01:32AM (#2772641)
There have been several large studies of identical twins separated at birth.

Yes, and I am closely acquainted, through attending their graduate student "journal club,"

http://www.psych.umn.edu/courses/fall10/psy8935/default.htm

with most of the researchers who have conducted the best of those studies. An earlier reply of mine here on HN

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2696680

corrects (with citations to current research publications) some of the overstatements seen in popular literature about what twin studies show. There is also not any single gene variant that has large effect on IQ, in the view of those researchers about what the most up-to-date gene association studies show.

Re:The Growing Divide Between Silicon Valley And Unemployed ... by erikpukinskis on Saturday July 16, 2011 @05:20PM (#2771841)
I believe there are genetic determinants of IQ. But I think IQ measures only one very specific kind of intelligence. Using IQ as a measure for intelligence is like using guitar skills as a measure of musical ability. There are other instruments too.