Trash article from someone trying to stay relevant.
> A neutral treatment would, of course, give broad factual coverage of such things as where the rioting took place, how many people were arrested, and numbers of injuries and deaths attributable to the rioting. The main Wikipedia article actually seems to do a good job there, as far as I can tell.
Sorry he said "good job" and I said "great job". I suppose there is a difference there and I apologize for that.
> The rest of the article—which, I confess, I did not read entirely, as it is very long
He cares so much about the bias that he can't be bothered to find it. The only thing I saw (and I mentioned in my original post) is that he took issue with the description of statue removal phrasing. So he skips through three long articles, doesn't read them all but finds what he's looking for. This is largely how people operate today, they start with what they want to believe then they go looking for it.
Also to your point: "This is largely how people operate today, they start with what they want to believe then they go looking for it."
If he went looking for it, he certainly found it very easily. I would agree with you if he had found the bias in niche topics and in later sections of articles much less likely to be read. But when the articles with the most traffic and most contributors demonstrate bias, its clear there is a problem.
> Why don't you quote his article and then the wikipedia "interpretation" that is "very biased"? Let's take concrete examples.
That's a request for concrete examples. Regardless, why don't you provide concrete examples of the liberal bias in those articles to back up your claims?
When did HN become worse than reddit?
Your use of the word "Let's" was either a suggestion or an order. Based on your tone it appears to have been an order XD
(He also said a lot of negative things about Wikileaks, cited in the Wikipedia article you link.)
I would hope that the mods would remove the flag.
Except OP's actual examples aren't of Wikipedia "picking a side", it's that Wikipedia is ignoring his side of things.
It's one thing to say Switzerland is going to stay neutral to the Nazis. But that doesn't mean Switzerland is somehow required to hand out Nazi leaflets that it is delivered.
"Switserland is handing out leaflets for the allies but not the axis".
Which would of course not be neutral.
I thought the dilemma of neutrality vs objectivity was also interesting. It seems these goals are directly at odds, and if you are writing an encyclopedia you can only achieve one. You can give multiple sides an even amount of attention, including a possibly, objectively wrong perspective. Or, you can forego neutrality and go for objectivity. But, many social issues are precisely subjective and fuzzy.
I understand wanting an objective picture, I can even imagine why fox news might not be top of the shelf journalism, but TFA makes a point: sometimes they can be the only ones reporting on a side. And if you are neutral, you must not take sides.
The example of Switserland was interesting, as they had to tolerate the nazis as well to remain truly neutral.
Do you want neutrality? Or objectivity? Then, what is objective in some of these issues, where we simply don't have all the information, or worse, fuzzy and subjective issues?