News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by l33t2328 on Friday July 02, 2021 @03:34AM (#27708772)
> so maybe the rule should be: if you use a human name for sw/hw solution, you should let it work only if it received the normal level of human empathy in communication

I’m extremely opposed to this, although I wouldn’t be against it being an optional disabled-by-default feature. I like having a human name to speak too(something about it clicks better than “okay google”).

If parents are struggling to teach their kids that people aren’t robots, perhaps the problem isn’t the technology, it’s the parents. The solution is not making it more inconvenient for me to play a song because I didn’t ask my phone as politely as I would a human.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by necovek on Friday July 02, 2021 @03:53AM (#27708906)
It could be as simple as "Hey Amazon Echo, respond to 'Alexa' from now on." during setup. For Amazon, the goal is to build a brand with "Alexa" ("Alexa" is more recognizable than "Echo" to most people — which is what resulted in jokes coincidentally): requiring users to name their software assistant would not have ruined the experience for anyone.

I don't have a smart speaker in my home, but personally I wouldn't care what the name is if I treated it as a "robot" as long as it flows off the tongue well. "Hey Q, start vacuuming" is perfectly fine to me.

The best way to empathize is to imagine if it was your name given as the wake word for the product. To imagine the confusion and how quickly it gets old, you can also imagine it was "Nick".

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Friday July 02, 2021 @03:58AM (#27708940)
Saying please to a device is no effort and always saying please is a better habit to learn than the alternative of forgetting to say please when speaking to a person.

Imagine being upset that someone suggests you say please to Alexa.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by l33t2328 on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:29AM (#27710578)
Saying please to a device is some effort I don’t want to have to do for it to work.

I’m not mad about it, I’m saying it’s objectively a bad feature.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:49AM (#27710810)
> it’s objectively a bad feature.

It's subjective, and no it isn't bad.

Your argument is "I don't want to" and that is as far from objective as one can get.

--

There is at least some logic presented for using Alexa as a tool for kids (and adults) to learn, practice, and habitualise their manners. That is an objective argument.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by l33t2328 on Friday July 02, 2021 @05:45PM (#27717325)
It’s objectively a bad feature because it requires the user to add extra steps to their input for no benefit.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by Jenk on Friday July 02, 2021 @07:36PM (#27718132)
... except for the benefit already explained and, seemingly, with zero detriment because you and the other "I don't want to say please" brigadiers haven't come up with anything.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by l33t2328 on Saturday July 03, 2021 @04:11PM (#27724497)
That “benefit” is tenuous at best. Making this feature mandatory or default would be an objective downgrade, but I’ll grant that it would be a solid optional feature.
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by necovek on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:53AM (#27710859)
Why do you want a device to have a name, let alone a human one, at all?

Having no name at all is much better, and more in line with all the sci-fi we've been through. "Play music" is sufficient, and less work. It's up to the tool to figure out if you are talking to another person or not, of course.

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by majewsky on Friday July 02, 2021 @12:18PM (#27713482)
Ah, if only all our problems could be solved by handwaving away the hard part (in this case, distinguishing commands directed at the machine from other speech, including voice lines on the TV).
Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by necovek on Friday July 02, 2021 @03:55PM (#27716050)
There were several solutions presented earlier (do not use a human name, make every owner choose a name) that are possible right now and do not cause any of the issues a current choice has.

This was a proposal for where we should be going if we care about the even terser communication (which was the argument being made), and where ultimately, voice assistants are surely going (otherwise, if we do not develop speaker-recognition ["there are two persons talking, look for extra hints that message is aimed for me"] and tone recognition, home-integrated ones will soon be unlocking doors for thiefs who can shout "Alexa, unlock doors" or "open windows" loud enough, or, you know, using a loudspeaker).

Re:Parents of children called Alexa challenge Amazon by forty on Friday July 02, 2021 @03:42AM (#27708836)
I have a hard time imagining that "r2d2 play a song" is much more inconvenient than saying Alexa ;)