News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Silhouette on Thursday July 01, 2021 @05:22PM (#27705041)
There is also no legal basis for requiring radio controllers to have signature enforced firmware loading.

If someone actually tried to write their own radio firmware and made a mistake, there very soon would be.

Messing around with radio transmission is not a game. Make enough noise on the wrong frequency and now you're interfering with communications for emergency services responding to a disaster or air traffic control guiding flights in crowded airspace, with a very real danger of loss of life. And there is no way for anyone to stop you until they've physically tracked down the source of the bad transmission, which can take hours.

I am very much in favour of rights to repair and against almost any restriction on what individuals can do with their own hardware, but giving people who don't know what they're doing unrestricted access to a radio transmitter on that basis is a bit like giving everyone in your city a button that detonates the nuke because you believe in a right to bear arms. At some point, you need to draw a line and say only qualified people past this point, or very bad things start to happen.

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by jsight on Thursday July 01, 2021 @06:26PM (#27705642)
People can buy software defined radios and effectively already have that access.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by bluGill on Friday July 02, 2021 @08:40AM (#27710719)
Note that for engines the EPA has been cracking down on all the mods that bypass software emission controls. The fines (though rare from what I know) have been large to small scale people selling such things. You can probably still make/mod your own engine by yourself, but if you sell and engine mod software you better meet emissions - I suspect that they will crack down on "free" open source mods as well which will kill collaboration (unless those involved are extremely careful to meet emission standards).

The FCC hasn't cracked down - yet. As other have pointed out that is probably because they don't see a widespread problem and so the politics aren't worth it. I'm sure someone reading this is involved with radio, I hope they take the warning (I believe their response will be a form of we already know)

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Silhouette on Friday July 02, 2021 @09:21AM (#27711158)
Indeed. Not a lot of people are interested enough to experiment with radio transmission and fortunately the ones who are tend to be keen hobbyists who understand how the systems work and take care not to break things for everyone else.

The kinds of outage that can be caused by rogue transmitters are rare. Often it's a hardware failure that is to blame when they do happen. Hardware failures are also rare but when you might have millions of transmitters within a small city, sometimes you discover that rare is not the same as never!

There is always the possibility of malicious or negligent interference if an operator has the ability to modify their transmitter's behaviour sufficiently though. I would personally be OK with limiting the sale or use of equipment with those capabilities to only people who have shown they are competent, for much the same reasons that I am personally OK with restricting the use of cars to people who have passed a test. It obviously doesn't prevent all failures but it certainly lowers the risk of failures that could endanger many other people.

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by R0b0t1 on Thursday July 01, 2021 @07:41PM (#27706261)
People do this all the time with routers. The FCC has been trying to require firmware signing but it has been pushed off for now because there is very little demonstrable harm.

I can go buy a bunch of passives off of ebay and make a noisy oscillator that will kill everything for a couple blocks but nobody seems to do it.

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Silhouette on Thursday July 01, 2021 @11:01PM (#27707434)
I have seen the "very little demonstrable harm" you mentioned with my own eyes in real time. It was little more than serendipity that saved lives that day. If someone did do what you described then IMHO they would be recklessly endangering the lives of others and should be treated accordingly.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by R0b0t1 on Friday July 02, 2021 @12:09AM (#27707715)
This isn't a tenable argument for two reasons:

1. How far off the bell curve do we need to go? Do we trade all rights to do anything for diminishing returns in safety?

2. These modifications are happening right now. Bad instances are usually caught by EMS system tests or by people reporting gaps in cell coverage, etc, and are generally purpose build jammers. There are not many instances of frequency overlap. For most goods, especially consumer telecommunications equipment, other bands are protected by the fact the equipment is given a specific range to operate in anyway.

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Silhouette on Friday July 02, 2021 @03:17AM (#27708681)
I am having difficulty working out what your position is here. Before you were talking about taking out multi block areas. Now you're talking about consumer equipment that is prevented from interfering with other frequencies. I was objecting to the former -- wherever you choose to draw your line, clearly interfering with safety-critical communications over a wide area should be well past it. The latter is a prudent step for mass market consumer goods.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by netr0ute on Friday July 02, 2021 @07:56AM (#27710315)
What proof do you have? If you can't give a specific example, your argument might as well be corporate PR.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Silhouette on Friday July 02, 2021 @09:00AM (#27710923)
You're new here, so I will gently point out that this isn't Reddit and it certainly isn't Slashdot. Asking everyone for proof of everything or implying that they are shilling is boring and unconstructive.

I've been on HN for more than a decade. You can check my comment history to see that I contribute sensibly. I have no reason to make anything about this up, but I'm obviously not going to doxx myself by providing the kind of proof that would be convincing. You're free to take me at my word or to disbelieve me, but if you aren't interested in substantial discussion in good faith, please consider simply ignoring a comment and moving on to something that interests you more.

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by netr0ute on Friday July 02, 2021 @09:08AM (#27711009)
I'm just interested in substantial discussion by wanting to know what exactly happened with modification of some radio device.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Silhouette on Friday July 02, 2021 @12:43PM (#27713835)
OK. You might like to consider adopting a less confrontational tone when commenting on HN in that case, as it generally doesn't go down well here.

The answer to your question is that I once spent some time working with a network operator and on a day when I happened to be around their operations centre there was an active incident like this.

If memory serves, it turned out that the rogue device was a relatively new model that a customer had bought and was trying to use normally but something wasn't reliably operating within spec. That model would have had to pass certification to be permitted on the network but apparently this specific unit had drifted and as a result it was dumping bad data all over a control channel that was in use across a large geographical area, causing severe disruption to connectivity for everyone.

At that time some safety-critical services were using this network for communications in the field so this kind of outage was a very big deal. There were multiple vehicles with detection equipment on the road, systematically trying to narrow down the source of the interference, but of course they had trouble coordinating with the operations centre themselves because of the same disruption. I don't know everything that was going on, but I did learn that in my country there is a legal power to gain access to premises in this kind of situation and it sounded like the required formalities and officials were being arranged just in case.

As I recall, it took most of an afternoon to track down the source of the interference and get it switched off. In the end it was mostly dumb luck that it was found. I didn't quite follow what happened but possibly a detection vehicle that was out of contact with the operations centre had decided to patrol in its area until it could find another way to call in and while it was doing that it drove right past the building where the rogue unit was located and its detection equipment lit up like a Christmas tree.

The customer was entirely innocent and had no idea it was their unit causing all the trouble nor any reason they should have known. I don't know exactly what happened to that model, the manufacturer or the certification process it had managed to pass despite the defect. For sure there were serious repercussions.

This all happened some time ago and the protocols and networks have since changed but the physics hasn't. That's why I have such strong views about regulation and only allowing people who know what they're doing to have full control over transmission equipment. As the above incident shows, things can still go badly wrong even without that. If there had been a major incident requiring coordination between first responders in the field during that downtime it could have been disastrous. Minimising the risk of similar failures due to carelessness by someone who didn't fully understand their equipment and the systems and protocols they were working with just seems like common sense to me.

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by aaronfitz on Friday July 02, 2021 @04:21PM (#27716402)
It sounds like the device was defective, not modified. This is a poor example for your assertion.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Silhouette on Friday July 02, 2021 @07:34PM (#27718125)
Which assertion is that? My contention since my very first comment has always been that messing around with radio transmission when you don't know what you're doing is dangerous. My anecdote was an illustration of what actually happened when incorrect transmission broke a system for real, how dangerous the situation became, and how difficult it was to fix.

Maybe you disagree but I think the fact that the cause of the incorrect transmission was a hardware fault in that particular anecdote is relevant only if we don't think a user with the ability to freely modify firmware as we were discussing could cause exactly the same effect either negligently or maliciously. Otherwise, the argument being made is merely that not many people actually modify firmware in dangerous ways, in which case I refer you to the nuclear analogy in my original comment.

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by netr0ute on Friday July 02, 2021 @10:53PM (#27718995)
The problem is, the kinds of problems caused by modification of the radio and a manufacturing mistake can be totally different and so things that you encountered you wouldn't see if someone simply modified it to operate on a different frequency. Therefore, your story which hinges on this difference not existing doesn't hold up.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Silhouette on Saturday July 03, 2021 @12:57AM (#27719461)
Actually, if you had reconfigured a device badly and it had ended up signalling incorrectly on a network's control channel as a result, the situation I encountered is exactly what you would have seen on that day. Do you understand what a control channel is and why it is relevant here?
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by netr0ute on Saturday July 03, 2021 @07:41AM (#27720943)
I'm thinking of if the radio had a component failure/missing and the wave it produced was either amplified or modified to be something like a square wave. It would be hard to do the latter with a simple software mod but easy with hardware.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by netr0ute on Friday July 02, 2021 @05:08PM (#27716891)
That's not intentional modification, just bad quality control from the manufacturer.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Silhouette on Friday July 02, 2021 @07:57PM (#27718240)
The point is that exactly the same outcome could be caused by intentional modification. As I said in my reply to bluGill earlier, the goal is not to eliminate all risk of interference, but to reduce the risk as much as reasonably possible by controlling the potential sources where you can. Given that interference potentially causes catastrophic loss of life in this scenario, not to mention inconvenience to huge numbers of people, that seems like a good idea.

Put another way, you're not trying to prevent people who know what they're doing and follow robust processes from developing radio transmitters, even though in extreme cases such as my anecdote that might still not be enough to prevent a system failure. Nor can you realistically stop a sufficiently resourceful adversary from using radio interference as a form of attack. What you can do is stop an enthusiastic newbie who read an article about radio once from accidentally causing people to die because their experiment meant emergency responders at an incident down the street couldn't talk to each other except face to face.

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by netr0ute on Thursday July 01, 2021 @07:09PM (#27706025)
You say all this as if the megacorps with signed firmware can't make mistakes.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Silhouette on Thursday July 01, 2021 @10:45PM (#27707381)
Of course they can. But usually they don't, not for something like this.

I have been witness to the kind of search I mentioned. Usually it happens because of a freak hardware failure, not a malicious act or negligence. Unfortunately the innocence of all involved does not reduce the severity of the potential consequences. As I said, this stuff is not a game.