News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by dodobirdlord on Thursday July 01, 2021 @11:45AM (#27700342)
Sometimes they will seek out nearby open WiFi networks to join. There’s concern that in coming years with the spread of 5G availability that smart TVs may start packaging a 5G modem and connecting to cell networks, bypassing the need to be connected to a WiFi network.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by tshaddox on Thursday July 01, 2021 @12:21PM (#27700807)
Why would 5G make that be a more viable choice for the TV manufacturers than existing widespread cellular networks?
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by rocqua on Thursday July 01, 2021 @01:04PM (#27701425)
Because 5G is intentionally marketed as having this functionality. It helps by allowing more efficient low-speed connections, and simpler radio design for very simple implementation. It also has 'slicing' which would make it much easier to provide a wide 5G network to e.g. all LG devices without LG building towers.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by ectopod on Thursday July 01, 2021 @12:37PM (#27701034)
As I understand it, the standard allows a single tower to offer different quality of service levels so operators can sell cheap low bandwidth connections to IoT manufacturers. TVs wouldn't have modems before because no TV manufacturer wanted to pay for a full 3G or 4G connection.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by handrous on Thursday July 01, 2021 @12:37PM (#27701029)
It's supposed to enable much-cheaper options for IoT applications. If the cost of the chip + the cost of low-bandwidth access drops below the profit gained by ensuring all your TVs can always reach an unfiltered network, they'll start adding them.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by raxxorrax on Friday July 02, 2021 @06:06AM (#27709714)
Because getting the data about what people are watching plus maybe input from microphone/camera is more valuable than a contract with mobile carriers that would give good prices to vendors.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by deadbunny on Thursday July 01, 2021 @12:57PM (#27701309)
> Sometimes they will seek out nearby open WiFi networks to join

[Citation Needed]

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by fouric on Thursday July 01, 2021 @02:57PM (#27703027)
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by deadbunny on Thursday July 01, 2021 @04:14PM (#27704127)
So one Reddit post with zero evidence that has since been deleted? While I understand the distrust I'll take some repeatable evidence (which would be excedingly easy to do) over a random, now deleted Reddit post.
Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by fouric on Thursday July 01, 2021 @06:19PM (#27705598)
> which would be excedingly easy to do

False. You would need to buy (or just randomly happen to have) a smart TV model that exhibits this characteristic, which would be very difficult to find, as there is a very wide spread of smart TV models and features, and obviously this "feature" wouldn't be advertised. This is neither easy nor free.

You're also clearly moving the goalposts. You first asked for evidence, and then discarded the evidence because "it wasn't good enough".

Nor is this capability either technically difficult to implement, illegal, easily-noticed by the average consumer, or abnormal for companies like Samsung, which already engage in highly-intrusive ad-surveillance activities[1].

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24662353

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by _carbyau_ on Thursday July 01, 2021 @07:33PM (#27706208)
While I am rather cynical about manufacturers of all sizes and their attitudes towards customers, I agree with the GP.

If this is a common thing, this should be easy to replicate. If it is one unverified reported incident in the whole world then... I have to be skeptical.

Don't get me wrong though, my innate cynicism expects this or similar via 5G to be coming in the near future. But it doesn't appear to be happening yet.

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by deadbunny on Friday July 02, 2021 @04:53AM (#27709258)
> False. You would need to buy (or just randomly happen to have) a smart TV model that exhibits this characteristic, which would be very difficult to find, as there is a very wide spread of smart TV models and features, and obviously this "feature" wouldn't be advertised. This is neither easy nor free.

If the reddit poster had provided model numbers, not just "Samsung TVs" this would become trivial to verify. They however did not. They also didn't provide any proof other than "it deffo happened guys".

> You're also clearly moving the goalposts. You first asked for evidence, and then discarded the evidence because "it wasn't good enough".

Again, as I stated in my reply while I understand your skepticism and distrust of the industry my standard of evidence is somewhat above one random guy on reddit with no verifiable evidence.

Re:British right to repair law excludes smartphones and comp... by Hamuko on Thursday July 01, 2021 @12:02PM (#27700558)
I can't wait to figure out how to run rtorrent on my 5G-enabled TV.