Re:GitHub Copilot as open source code laundering?
by diffeomorphism on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @10:50AM
(#27689238)
How is this different from uploading a hollywood movie to youtube? Just because there is a passage in the terms that the uploader supposedly gave them those rights, this does not mean they actually have the power to do that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:GitHub Copilot as open source code laundering?
by jcranmer on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @11:59AM
(#27690107)
You can't give Github or Youtube or anybody else copyright rights if you don't have them in the first place. This is what ultimately torpedoed "Happy Birthday" copyright claims: while it's pretty undisputed that the Hill sisters gave their copyright to (ultimately) Warner/Chapelle, it was the case that they actually didn't invent the lyrics, and thus Warner/Chapelle had no copyright over the lyrics.
So if someone uploads a Hollywood movie to Youtube, Youtube doesn't get the rights to play that movie from them because they didn't have the rights in the first place. Of course, if the actual copyright owner uploads it, it's now permissible for Youtube to play it, even if it's the copy that someone else provided. [This has torpedoed a few filesharing lawsuits.]
Re:GitHub Copilot as open source code laundering?
by macinjosh on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @11:46AM
(#27689933)
Not sure how much it would matter but the main difference I see is that if I upload my own code to GitHub I have the ability to give away the IP, but if I upload Avengers End Game to YouTube I don't have the right to give that away.
Re:GitHub Copilot as open source code laundering?
by makeitdouble on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @12:33PM
(#27690549)
I wonder how it would work if we consider you flagged your code as GPL before it hits Github.
We could end up in the same situation as the Hollywood movie even if you are also the one setting the original license on the work. Basically you have a right to change the license, but it doesn’t mean you do.