News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by aidenn0 on Friday July 15, 2011 @02:01PM (#2768405)
I'm not sure where you disagree with the posted article:

"Evolution is not teleological and genes do not "want". Genes just happen; they're chemicals. Working to ensure the continuation of your genes is not mandated or valuable -- it is likely.

This doesn't conflict with the article at all. The article never claims that humans have an ethical mandate to ensure the continuation of your genes. Furthermore your statement that this behavior is _likely_ actually agrees with the article.

"The other obvious problem is that societies which played into the competitive heirarchy were only successful for some weird definitions of successful.

I don't see where the article claims competitive heirarchies are more successful. About the closest I could find is that cultures who disproportionately use their men for high-risk roles are more successful than those who do not; but I don't see how this differentiated the British from the Mongols.

Re:Is There Anything Good About Men? by scythe on Friday July 15, 2011 @02:13PM (#2768459)
>About the closest I could find is that cultures who disproportionately use their men for high-risk roles are more successful than those who do not; but I don't see how this differentiated the British from the Mongols.

Oh, they both did -- no question about that -- but the Mongols did it a whole damn lot more, i.e. warrior society as opposed to civil society, and were arguably less successful, long term.