News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Thiel Has Accumulated $5B in a Roth IRA by dna_polymerase on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:28AM (#27676257)
The accounts are capped at a contribution of $6000 to $7000 per year. Thiel turned $2000 into this amount. I don't see the systemic problem here. And I see the government's entitlement to taxes on that even less.

Whatever Thiel is like as a person, as a businessman he has been connected to the big things in the past two decades like no one else. Give the man a break.

Also, I love these hit pieces on Forbes and the other news sites, followed by a native advertisement. "F! the capitalist for making money, but really give us money"!

Re:Peter Thiel Has Accumulated $5B in a Roth IRA by TrueGeek on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:34AM (#27676342)
> Thiel turned $2000 into this amount

Is there a history of what trades he made and over what period? A $2k investment to $5B is insane.

Re:Peter Thiel Has Accumulated $5B in a Roth IRA by spamizbad on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:42AM (#27676482)
The "trick" is you put your near-worthless startup stock into the fund before any major valuations. So when your company shares are worth $0.01 or whatever, you put in a few thousand dollars worth of them each year before you valuation skyrockets.

Assuming the company goes public, the shares stay in the Roth. IANAL but I assume you lose Roth benefits and probably pay some penalties if the company gets sold for cash.

Re:Peter Thiel Has Accumulated $5B in a Roth IRA by nrmitchi on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:48AM (#27676580)
As discussed previously, this "trick" is actually explicitly not permitted, because you could do something like say "My stock is only work $0.001 each ;)" while simultaneously selling to investors are orders-of-magnitude higher valuations.

I mean, let's be real: the argument in defense of this is that Thiel bought his founders shares at "a fair value". There were 3 original founders, so the argument is that the company had a fair value of.... ~$5k?

> you put in a few thousand dollars worth of them each year before you valuation skyrockets

You can't transfer assets into an IRA like this either.

Re:Peter Thiel Has Accumulated $5B in a Roth IRA by spamizbad on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:50AM (#27676621)
So how'd he do it?
Re:Peter Thiel Has Accumulated $5B in a Roth IRA by nrmitchi on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:58AM (#27676737)
What do you mean? Just because something is a prohibited transaction doesn't mean there is a magical fairly that ensures you don't. I'm sure you are aware that the audit-rate for wealthy individuals is (and was) significantly lower than other income brackets.

There is no magical automated system that is going to catch and flag a not-arms-length transaction, and I'm sure he (well, his legal team) is sitting around saying "well it's a shame this wasn't caught at the time, you know, statute of limitations and such".

Re:Peter Thiel Has Accumulated $5B in a Roth IRA by blfr on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:46AM (#27676552)
I've read another story about his IRA that I cannot find now and he started with his PayPal shares, then used proceeds from that for Facebook and other investments for which he's famous. This was not a public/stock investment strategy.

It's less impressive that it could have been(!) because he took out some money (and paid taxes on it).

Re:Peter Thiel Has Accumulated $5B in a Roth IRA by jeremysalwen on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:38AM (#27676411)
You can actually put ~50k per year into a Roth ira using the mega backdoor technique. Still impressive.
Re:Peter Thiel Has Accumulated $5B in a Roth IRA by colinmhayes on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:46AM (#27676564)
He bought 1.7 million paypal shares for $1,700. They were worth 50 million a couple years later. After that it's just a bun ch of venture capital stuff, including facebook.