News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by Faaak on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:15AM (#27676043)
> Or if all medical data was public, we'd have a medical revolution in understanding.

No, your insurance premium would go up. That's it

Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:20AM (#27676134)
In the US, health insurance premiums are (by law) based on age, location, and smoking status only. Highest premiums (age 64) are capped at 3x the premium of ages 21 to 24.
Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by asah on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:37AM (#27676392)
Is the coverage also mandated? How about the adjudication process? How about the amount of effort to successfully file a claim?

As a hypothetical, consider a process requiring each claim to be submitted in person, 9-10am on Mondays, down an alleyway in Toledo, 4 week turnaround, and then resubmitted 6 times before it's approved. It's not quite this bad, but everybody has a horror story and (unlike auto and home owner's insurance), I've heard nobody say anything nice about their health insurance company.

(I'm working on a winning team fixing this at national scale, DM if interested)

Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:43AM (#27676504)
Yes, health insurers have to cover anyone. There is an appeal process where a third party is required to arbitrate if you feel the insurer is not approving payment for something inappropriately. I have not experienced it, nor do I know anyone who has, so I do not know what that experience is like.

I do not know what nobody saying anything nice about health insurance companies means. Although, I do know from experience, that most people are not knowledgeable about many businesses, but they do like to opine on how things should be. Insurance in general is bound to have unhappy customers, whether or not justified. People interact with health insurance more than any other, so I would expect a lot more complaints.

I do not doubt that managed care organizations (health insurance companies) have screwed over people. But that probably applies to any large organization. I have not seen evidence that they do so on a systemic basis, however.

Note that they are often administering rules made by others, such as private employers or governments (Medicare/Medicaid). In these cases, I think part of their role is to serve as a third party who the decision maker (private employer or politicians) can point at when people get mad.

> (I'm working on a winning team fixing this at national scale, DM if interested)

One thing for sure is there are many improvements that can be made. Best of luck!

Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by deregulateMed on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @01:09PM (#27678748)
My insurance company gets me lower costs than the hospital would otherwise provide.

It's a guarantee that I don't pay more than 8000$/yr for healthcare.

Without the insurance company, I might be in debt after a hospital visit. If the medical cartels weren't so corrupt and I could get a price, I probably wouldn't use insurance.

Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by extraduder_ire on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @11:52AM (#27677658)
I am an interested rando, where do I DM you? Is this another feature of hn that I haven't unlocked yet?
Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @11:55AM (#27677713)
It means click on their username and email them or go to whatever link is in their profile.
Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by brianwawok on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:32AM (#27676314)
The 3x cap is not universal, and what it ultimately does is raise the price of insurance for younger and healthier groups. Smaller groups are exempt from that requirement.

Since my company skews younger/healthier than the average company (hey we are a startup after all, new to this) - we are able to join a state commerce association and get rates calculated on our actual risk, which saves us roughly half over the national pool. I think it also takes full medical history into account, to again give us lower rates.

But of course the global effect of this, is as younger and healthier groups leave the national pool - those left gets even HIGHER rates, as the super profitable healthy young people are gone. And the more the global pool rates go up, the more people pull out. Until the national pool is only sick and old groups, with insane rates.

Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:34AM (#27676353)
Yes, that was one of the unfortunate compromises that had to be made to get ACA passed. We could not get taxpayer funded healthcare passed, so they tried to dump everyone on the insurance market. Then the people that work at healthy, younger white collar firms balked at subsidizing others, so they were left out.

We Americans are quite good at making systems that benefit others just enough to create plausible deniability, but with enough loopholes to evade helping shoulder the burden, if you are playing with the right cards.

Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by brianwawok on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @11:32AM (#27677328)
Yah it's just a silly system.

We need full universal healthcare. These other things are just a mess.

Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @11:39AM (#27677446)
Conceptually, I think the MCO (managed care organization) system works as well. In a taxpayer funded system, the MCO activities are performed by government employees directly. In an MCO system, there is some extra overhead, but MCO profit margins are 5% or less, so it is not terrible. It is just that everyone needs to be forced to go through healthcare.gov, and I don’t see why Medicare or Medicaid should even be a thing. The hodge podge of systems is the worst of all worlds.

Of course, I know why it is a hodge podge, and that is because increasing the amount of healthcare available to everyone would increase costs and hence taxes and/or premiums.

Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by brianwawok on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @04:24PM (#27681246)
Maybe. But the current system means a lot of people never get care until things get real bad, and it's the ER. I am not sure the total price goes up with a full universal healthcare... but, a lot of large companies (blue cross, etc) are obsolete.
Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by misja111 on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:18AM (#27676089)
Why? It could also go down.
Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by nerdponx on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:21AM (#27676140)
Because there's no incentive for them to reduce prices.
Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @10:38AM (#27676423)
There are many competing managed care organizations (health insurers).

Healthcare cost increases slowed down after ACA:

https://www.cbpp.org/blog/more-evidence-of-post-aca-slowdown...

https://www.npr.org/2019/12/23/790687286/examining-health-ca...

Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by nerdponx on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @01:30PM (#27679084)
I believe the research, but I doubt the ACA slowed down increases due to competition. The studies you linked don't show evidence of it either.

Most people do not get to shop for insurance. Individual market plans are all similarly and eye-wateringly expensive (last I checked). And people getting health coverage through work are lucky if they have even two insurers to choose between.

Therefore I don't see any reason why insurance companies would uniformly lower their "baseline" premiums when given access to more information. If they were all competing for your business like car insurance, homeowner insurance, etc. things would be very different.

Re:LinkedIn breach reportedly exposes data of 92% of users, ... by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @04:05PM (#27681031)
My claim is that the rate of increase in healthcare costs decreasing is evidence that there is incentive to offer the lowest price possible (and health insurance premiums are a function of healthcare costs). If there was no incentive to offer lower pricing, then it does not make sense that healthcare costs would have slowed down when the number of people receiving healthcare greatly increased after ACA.

Also, health insurance is not like other insurance, and it is barely insurance at all. Over a lifetime, almost everyone will need healthcare, unlike car insurance and home insurance. Due to ACA's various rules around how health insurance can be priced and who it has to be offered to (everyone), health insurance company is actually a misnomer.

I prefer to use the industry term managed care organization (MCO), as it more accurately encompasses the function of what is colloquially known as a health insurance company. The price for individual market plans (which I assume you mean those on healthcare.gov) and the price for employer sponsored ones where the insurer is the one insuring the risk are all priced similarly, and they are eye wateringly expensive because healthcare is expensive.

Employers also shop around for premiums with various MCOs, they don't just choose one. The self insured employers (who pay for the healthcare themselves and just pay the MCO for access to pricing and administration of the health plan itself. I have never heard of anyone choosing between different MCOs at work, that would defeat the whole purpose and really complicate the non discrimination testing requirements.

Either way, MCOs certainly do have to compete with each other for business, if they're selling insurance plus managed care services or just managed care services. And so they cannot just lower or raise premiums at their whim. Bottom line is they do have an incentive to offer competitive pricing, it is not a high margin business to begin with.