News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Singularity is Far: A Neuroscientist's View by PaulHoule on Friday July 15, 2011 @09:00AM (#2767200)
I've never been impressed by the "simulate a single human" approach to AGI.

I don't know why it appeals to people. Has Christianity infected people with a desire for personal immortality? Are people inured to flushing billions and billions down the drain on biomedical research?

Another issue is that humans aren't that great anyway. The "game of life" is really about statistical inference and people aren't that good at it -- the success of Las Vegas proves it. If you can eliminate the systematic biases that people make dealing with uncertainty, you can make intelligence which is qualitatively superhuman, not just quantitatively superhuman.

It's much more believable that steady progress will be made on emulating and surpassing human faculties. This won't be based on any one particular methodology (symbol processing, neural nets, Bayesian networks) but will be based on picking and choosing what works. Progress is going to be steady here because progress means better systems each step of the way.

Sure, the Richard Dreyfuses will be with us each step of the way and will diminish our accomplishments... and they might still be doing so long after we're living in a zoo.

Re:The Singularity is Far: A Neuroscientist's View by true_religion on Friday July 15, 2011 @09:50AM (#2767337)
> The "game of life" is really about statistical inference and people aren't that good at it -- the success of Las Vegas proves it.

Las Vegas is run by human beings. Having members of your species be worse at a task than other members of your species doesn't prove that your species as a whole is not good at the task.

Now...

> Has Christianity infected people with a desire for personal immortality? Are people inured to flushing billions and billions down the drain on biomedical research?

Why wouldn't one want personal immortality? To be fair, religious groups are those least likely to support personal immortality of many sorts (e.g. brain uploading) because of questions such as "what happens to the soul", and "isn't this meddling in our creators work?".

Rather, I'd think that anyone who believes that this life is all that exists would want to prolong it indefinitely. It's better to be than not to be.

Do you have an argument against that?

Re:The Singularity is Far: A Neuroscientist's View by evilduck on Friday July 15, 2011 @11:19AM (#2767672)
Do you have an argument against that?

Certainly: quality of life. Immortality may be a miserable, horrible existence. Most of the things we derive happiness from in life are an integral part of our normal life-death cycle of events, disrupting that cycle may not be very pleasant long-term unless we can supplant those innate desires with something equally fulfilling. We don't really know, it's never happened.

Re:The Singularity is Far: A Neuroscientist's View by randallsquared on Friday July 15, 2011 @12:32PM (#2768032)
disrupting that cycle may not be very pleasant long-term

Well, let's think about it for a few hundred years and have this discussion again, okay?

Re:The Singularity is Far: A Neuroscientist's View by true_religion on Friday July 15, 2011 @01:02PM (#2768164)
Death is one way. Immortality is usually not. You can always cease to be if you think that existence is horrible.
Re:The Singularity is Far: A Neuroscientist's View by cpeterso on Friday July 15, 2011 @08:01PM (#2769632)
> Most of the things we derive happiness from in life are an integral part of our normal life-death cycle of events

Most? Do you mind elaborating?

Re:The Singularity is Far: A Neuroscientist's View by evilduck on Saturday July 16, 2011 @10:43AM (#2770849)
Most of your desires and goals are related to the scarcity of time. In a broad sense, having children for example is a rewarding experience for people, we have an innate desire to reproduce and rear children (talk to any childless post-30 woman who didn't explicitly choose that situation, you'll see it's innate), but it's also something we probably wouldn't continue to do should death be removed from humanity, there'd be no need. But in a smaller sense, even something like enjoying a nice meal with friends would be called into question. Your enjoyment of food only exist because we've got a biologically programmed taste for foods that assists in our survival, and social interaction in an infinite time scale even gets weird, everyone would eventually know everyone and know everything there is to know, unique life experiences would become commonality, etc.

Things get weird on infinite scales.

Re:The Singularity is Far: A Neuroscientist's View by rcxdude on Sunday July 17, 2011 @09:53AM (#2773302)
there's a lot of assumptions in that particular view of immortality. It assumes that it would also mean infinite memory, a loss of senses and certain capabilities, and that we cannot modify ourselves to create new urges. All of these are possible and plausible, but for example in the simulated AI situation only the loss of senses is likely to be true (as well as perhaps the inability to modify ourselves, depending on the approach)
Re:The Singularity is Far: A Neuroscientist's View by randallsquared on Friday July 15, 2011 @09:34AM (#2767285)
Has Christianity infected people with a desire for personal immortality?

Where by "Christianity" you mean the Epic of Gilgamesh?

Anyway, simulating a human has the main bonus that we don't have to fully understand how intelligence works to make progress.

Re:The Singularity is Far: A Neuroscientist's View by fbailey on Friday July 15, 2011 @11:32AM (#2767735)
You were faster, but a littlebit unclear.

The desire for personal immortality is the oldest known human desire, it's written down in the oldest story we know http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gilgamesh, or still standing in the pyramids and similar burial places all over the world.