News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hurd Progresses - Debian GNU/Hurd by end of 2012? by onan_barbarian on Friday July 15, 2011 @08:06AM (#2767083)
Serious question: what's this for? It doesn't seem to be an interesting research project, and shows no sign of being useful in a pragmatic sense.

Surely a clean-sheet design started _now_ would be more interesting and perhaps even useful than a 21-year-old microkernel. Think about all the changes in architecture, networks, storage, etc.

We're in a world with consumer processors with 4-8 cores and hardware multithreading, GPUs that rival or exceed (in certain domains) the processing grunt of the CPUs, network cards that can talk to L2 cache, SSDs, etc.

Surely enough has changed that a clean-sheet design could be a lot more exciting - and even more practical - than trying to finish a design that hasn't succeeded for 2 decades. A clean-sheet design would at least be interesting - we already know you can build a workable system on top of a microkernel.

This isn't a claim to know what a clean sheet design would look like; I haven't really looked seriously at OS research in 15 years. I just strongly suspect you might do radically different, interesting designs in 2011 vs 1990.

Re:Hurd Progresses - Debian GNU/Hurd by end of 2012? by bruce511 on Friday July 15, 2011 @10:10AM (#2767402)
As far as I can tell it's more of a political statement than a goal to somehow deliver a better OS. RS has never been all that happy with Linux being the poster child for free software, especially since the ideological goals of Linux are not the same for the FSF. Witness the fact that Linux is GPL2 not GPL3 and isn't going to GPL3.

At the end of the day it provides an OS to the FSF which they can control, and which isn't Linux. Even if it was in all ways equal to Linux in performance, and features (which seems doubtful) it's unlikely that it would deploy to any great extent.

Just like ReactOS is pretty much "pointless" (given that Windows costs basically nothing), Hurd is practically pointless because it competes with Linux purely on ideological grounds, and is arguably an inferior product. It simply doesn't have enough differentiating it at this point for anyone to really care.

On the other hand, maybe they'll finish it before I die, and maybe it'll contain some ground-breaking improvement, and we'll all be eating humble pie. Anything is possible. In the meantime if they want to carry on working on it, then good for them. Isn't that what open-source is all about?

Re:Hurd Progresses - Debian GNU/Hurd by end of 2012? by rkwz on Friday July 15, 2011 @10:22AM (#2767439)
>Surely a clean-sheet design started _now_ would be more interesting and perhaps even useful than a 21-year-old microkernel.

Just curious, are there any such OS in development?

Re:Hurd Progresses - Debian GNU/Hurd by end of 2012? by p9idf on Friday July 15, 2011 @11:35AM (#2767751)
Sape Mullender and Noah Evans from Bell Labs announced last year that they are working on a system called Osprey. There's video of the talk floating around somewhere.
Re:Hurd Progresses - Debian GNU/Hurd by end of 2012? by tybris on Friday July 15, 2011 @10:52AM (#2767554)
[deleted]
Re:Hurd Progresses - Debian GNU/Hurd by end of 2012? by danieldk on Friday July 15, 2011 @08:32AM (#2767144)
That isn't the point of the parent. Anything that is not better than the current kernels is a waste of time.

I am sure someone will chime in that the Hurd is a microkernel. Microkernels have been around for decades, and did not gain much traction. (Perhaps with the notable exception of Darwin, but this is a single-server kernel.)

Something like Singularity/Midori is actually interesting, since it provides memory protection in the kernel, but without the expensive context switches.

Edit: yes, deleting messages is going to improve the flow of conversation :p.