Re:Dear Google: Public domain compositions exist
by krferriter on Monday June 28, 2021 @01:28PM
(#27664771)
Google can use the automated system while also cracking down on false copyright claims, using a strikes system for them too, and by not just handing the video revenue to the claim maker just because they make it. They can stash the revenue in a sort of escrow bucket until the copyright claim is actually resolved in either party's favor.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Dear Google: Public domain compositions exist
by ThrustVectoring on Monday June 28, 2021 @07:35PM
(#27669733)
Google cannot categorically ignore copyright claims without opening themselves up to potential legal liability. If you've made a hundred bogus copyright complaints to Google and they cut off your access, and you send in another complaint, they still have to either A) shove it into a DMCA safe-harbor exception, or B) risk knowingly continuing to violate your copyright. Option B is straight up not happening when the risk is that high, not without expensive lawyers reviewing the situation.
There isn't and will never be a "strikes" system for false copyright claims.
Re:Dear Google: Public domain compositions exist
by philderbeast on Monday June 28, 2021 @08:17PM
(#27670027)
they can deny access to content ID, and require manually submitted claims (providing a postal address and requiring hard copy notifications still meets the DMCA requirement's AFAIK)
so while they cant just ignore a claim, they can make it harder to make a claim.