News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Google: Public domain compositions exist by dragonwriter on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:21AM (#27662339)
> If creators have to work under a "3 copyright strikes" Sword of Damocles[1], the accounts of people making copyright claims need similar restriction.

Since you reference federal law and not a Google-specific policy here, perhaps the issue is Congress, nto Google.

Re:Dear Google: Public domain compositions exist by zamalek on Monday June 28, 2021 @10:25AM (#27662395)
The Google process pre-empts DCMA, that's the real problem. Congress has already considered fraudulent claims, but Google has/will not.
Re:Dear Google: Public domain compositions exist by dragonwriter on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:53PM (#27664306)
> The Google process pre-empts DCMA, that's the real problem

The reference to federal law wasn't to the DMCA safe harbor, but to the repeat-infringer termination rule. The Google termination process fulfills that requirement rather than preempting it.

> Congress has already considered fraudulent claims, but Google has/will not.

Insofar as the first part is true, its only in the sense that Congress essentially gave carte blanche to fradulent claims since the only consequence for false takedown notices apply only to the assertion of ownership or representation of the owner of some asserted copyright, not the part where you claim that someone is using the copyright protected material in an infringing manner.

Re:Dear Google: Public domain compositions exist by kevingadd on Monday June 28, 2021 @12:43PM (#27664157)
The Youtube system is not required by federal law. It's a worse system they created themselves.