News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Roblox on Linux with recent Wine 6.11 by pizza234 on Sunday June 27, 2021 @12:27PM (#27652894)
88 out of the 100 top Steam games are not representative of desktop gaming in general, even less "crushing" windows, where games run out of the box, and as intended ("platinum").

The value 88(%) is also misleading. It represents games running at least at bronze level (the lowest quality of a playable game). The percentage of perfectly running games (via Proton) is 15%.

I support Proton as a shortcut to release Linux-compatible games, but there's no comparison, in the big picture.

Re:Roblox on Linux with recent Wine 6.11 by Zhyl on Sunday June 27, 2021 @12:35PM (#27652975)
But running out of the box with no tweaks includes Gold, Platinum and Native which is far more than 50%.

I'm less about trying to imply that Linux is "crushing" Windows and more about it being seen as a viable option (i.e. " not a million miles away").

I think I'm against out of hand dismissal, which your post and the post I responded to are without qualification or balance.

Re:Roblox on Linux with recent Wine 6.11 by pizza234 on Monday June 28, 2021 @04:59AM (#27659516)
To be clear, I don't dismiss Proton/Wine at all.

I didn't intend "shortcut" as derogative (bad word choice :)); rather, given the limited resources of game development, it may make Linux ports possible (as opposed to native ports, which take significantly more resources). John Carmack actually supports this approach.

My criticism is that while there is the impression/hope that at some point the "emulation" will be completed, based on my experience (with Wine and ReactOS), it never will - it's a virtually infinite amount of new hacks/tweaks/small additions.

My conclusion is it a type of work that will require continuous employment of (development resources), and will be more of a workaround, than a solution. (regarding the "crush", this was actually in reference to an ancestor post)

Including native ports in the discussion, or excluding them, is a tricky discussion, which I consider separate - my points were about Wine/Proton specifically.

I actually do play games, but even if my O/S is Linux (and essentially all the games are on Steam), I still run games in a VM.

Re:Roblox on Linux with recent Wine 6.11 by Zhyl on Tuesday June 29, 2021 @09:20AM (#27675393)
Thanks for the clarification, that makes a lot of sense.