It's very similar to the countless existing services that rely on email for identity... you'd just have to verify ownership of the new email address (usually through a confirmation email).
At the very best this technology offers considerably less value to websites and more hassle to users than Facebook or Google. And it's about 5 years too late.
And how is this different than the current situation? Nearly all web sites require an email address. With BrowserID, you at some point confirmed ownership of that email address, so you could continue to use it to login, then change when you're ready.
"At the very best this technology offers considerably less value to websites and more hassle to users than Facebook or Google. And it's about 5 years too late."
Tell that to users who a) don't have Facebook accounts or b) don't want to use Google or Facebook with their identity. Far more people have email addresses than Facebook or Google accounts.
The question is whether a BrowserID identity is as useful as one of the established identity providers. You start out with a chicken-and-egg problem; websites won't consume BrowserID if users aren't using it, and users won't use it if websites aren't asking for it. What will overcome this Catch-22? Techwise, the dependence on email seems less compelling than Facebook or Google auth.
Maybe BrowserID can rely on mass distrust of Facebook and Google. I'm not sure that's sufficient though - especially with Google.
google auth is just one provider of the same identity as browserID-- an email login. so, imo, browserID is a strict improvement, in that it is more seamless than google auth in regular usage (leveraging the browser as the user agent), and works with more providers.
(One work-around would be to use an disposable e-mail address service and redirect your emails as needed.)
What a weird double-standard. A feature of email (that you can have several, and you can change which one you use) is a failure, and a failure of Facebook (that it's one site, forever) is a feature?
We're all familiar with ways to migrate from one email address to another. If/when you leave Facebook/it disappears, how will you migrate your identity then?
My Facebook account is an identity first and foremost. People do not typically have multiple Facebook accounts (a TOS violation). If that account goes away, that identity goes away.
You might make an argument that websites should allow you to aggregate multiple identities (Facebook, Google+, MS, Yahoo, etc) into a single account, or that there should be some sort of an identity provider that creates an aggregate identity across all those services. To an extent some of these websites are already doing something like this peer-to-peer - Facebook is an OpenID consumer, for example. Maybe sometime in the future this will be a big issue. But right now it isn't, and email-as-identity is already an annoying problem.
Now imagine 5 years ago you said "My Friendster account is an identity first and foremost."
On the other hand, email is already known to be an unstable key for identity. And the "market" for identity providers is a lot more mature than it was 5 years ago. Besides, what if Friendster had established itself as a public identity provider 5 years ago? Maybe we would be using Friendster instead of Facebook today. Who knows.
Would be happier if there was only one company that provided email service and you were only allowed to have one address? That's essentially the situation with Facebook.
You're free to apply whatever constraints you like to your use of email. An email address is as unstable an identity as you make it.
Two close friends of mine were the #2 and #4 employees of Friendster. I seriously considered becoming #3. I had a pretty good outsider's view of the early years.
Yeah, they screwed up the scaling pretty badly. But even worse they screwed up the business - after you set up your profile and looked around, there wasn't much more to do (unless you were single and looking). People were already using Friendster as an identity (emailing links as a "you mean this person, right?"). Maybe if they'd opened an API and enabled third-party apps, they could have maintained this position. It's a big "what if" but it can't be dismissed outright.
In a practical "on the internet sense," your email really is your identity (maybe SSN or name would be a better description; you can change it, but to do so is catastrophically disruptive). After all if you can't be contacted you really can't be identified, and the universal way of contacting someone online is through email.
Now, you should definitely try and provide some redundancy (store multiple email addresses, long living sessions, whatever) and make your anonymous/unauthenticated/drive-by user experience stellar. But when push comes to shove if you can't send them a "forgot your username/password/open-id/samoflange" email, you've lost that user.
(anecdote: I've had the same primary email for >7 years)
the team is in talks now about cooperation with another mozilla labs project centered around 1-off email generation for quick and easy anonymity with sites
I should be able to change my email address (and/or email hosting provider) without changing my identity on a bazillion sites around the internet. Facebook got this right from the beginning. Google is sort-of getting this, although the chasm between Google Accounts and Google Apps Accounts makes this really messy.
Really this product should be called BrowserEmailAddress, not BrowserID. It doesn't serve identity.