Re:An Open Letter to Jeff Bezos
by tzs on Thursday July 14, 2011 @04:13PM
(#2764867)
I have no philosophical objection to collecting tax for states other than the one in which my employer is located, provided two things are done first:
1. Rates are simplified. I do not want to deal with every separate county, city, or special tax district that has its own rate. I want to be able to look up the rate I should charge based on just a 5 digit zip code.
2. Reporting is simplified. I do not want to deal with almost 50 different requirements for how to submit the collected taxes. Keep in mind that each state needs to know how much tax was collected in each tax district so that they can apportion it correctly, so at the very least they are going to want some kind of breakdown from me.
My suggestion to deal with #1 would be for the states to get together and create a single source for rate data, updated quarterly, so that merchants could grab all the rate data from one place.
For #2, my suggestion would be for the states to agree to collect for each other. I'm in Washington, so already have to collect tax for Washington sales, and am already set up to report the appropriate data to Washington. So why not make it so when I report to Washington, I report sales from all states? Washington can them break that out by state and send the appropriate money and distribution information to the other states. Same goes for the other states--California merchants would report all sales and pay all collected taxes to California, which would then pay Washington for the sales that were to Washington, and so on.
If it were done this way, it would have minimal impact on merchants. We'd basically just end up getting bigger tax tables than we now get, and submitting more data to where we already submit data.
1. Rates are simplified. I do not want to deal with every separate county, city, or special tax district that has its own rate. I want to be able to look up the rate I should charge based on just a 5 digit zip code.
2. Reporting is simplified. I do not want to deal with almost 50 different requirements for how to submit the collected taxes. Keep in mind that each state needs to know how much tax was collected in each tax district so that they can apportion it correctly, so at the very least they are going to want some kind of breakdown from me.
My suggestion to deal with #1 would be for the states to get together and create a single source for rate data, updated quarterly, so that merchants could grab all the rate data from one place.
For #2, my suggestion would be for the states to agree to collect for each other. I'm in Washington, so already have to collect tax for Washington sales, and am already set up to report the appropriate data to Washington. So why not make it so when I report to Washington, I report sales from all states? Washington can them break that out by state and send the appropriate money and distribution information to the other states. Same goes for the other states--California merchants would report all sales and pay all collected taxes to California, which would then pay Washington for the sales that were to Washington, and so on.
If it were done this way, it would have minimal impact on merchants. We'd basically just end up getting bigger tax tables than we now get, and submitting more data to where we already submit data.