News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by alain94040 on Thursday July 14, 2011 @02:56PM (#2764454)
The two serve a different purpose. No one thinks a Harvard MBA gives you an edge for bootstrapping your startup in your garage, and no one believes doing Techstars will help you run the division of a large corporation.

A better decision algorithm would be:

  1) figure out what you want to do in the future
  2) pick acoordingly
If you want my take on MBA vs. entrepreneurship, I blogged here (http://blog.fairsoftware.net/2009/08/12/the-cheapest-mba-pro...). Guess what: for entrepreneurs, taking the entrepreneurial route is better.
Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by damoncali on Thursday July 14, 2011 @04:51PM (#2765039)
That's just not true. Many, many successful startups have been started by MBAs from Harvard and elsewhere.

A friend of mine from business school started a tech company while in school. He then raised several million in VC, and is well on his way - I believe I just saw them on CNBC. The VC he raised money from was an alum from our school.

A B-School professor of mine with an MBA started and sold not one, but two companies for north of $10M. One wasn't tech related, one (the bigger one) was.

None of those three companies had anything resembling a "technical cofounder".

Those are just a few of the examples I can think of from my own personal business school network, and I went to a school well south of Harvard in the MBA pecking order.

The entrepreneurial path is a long one. Business school is two insanely fun-filled years of your life during which you will meet lots and lots of very smart, very interesting people, and yes, even a few entrepreneurs, past present and future. Outside of the absurd cost these days, there is absolutely no downside to taking a detour through a decent MBA program.

Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by ig1 on Thursday July 14, 2011 @03:22PM (#2764590)
Startups founded by Harvard MBA alumni:

  Direct Hit+
  Gilt Group*
  Hunch
  Starent*
  Viglink
  Yelp+
  Zynga*

  + Valued at over $500m
  * Valued at over $1bn
Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by davidw on Thursday July 14, 2011 @03:31PM (#2764632)
Former startups founded by college dropouts:

* Apple

* Microsoft

The fact that some people from a highly driven and intelligent group were successful at startups is not really significant in and of itself.

Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by ig1 on Thursday July 14, 2011 @03:43PM (#2764690)
No, but you can compare the success rate of Harvard and Techstars alumni is founding successful startups. Given Techstars has yet to produce one $100m+ startup in the last five years and Harvard is probably in the double digits, I reckon Harvard will win.

Sure it could just be the case that Harvard has more talented people in the first place, but I'm not sure what methodology you could use to remove that bias.

Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by bigohms on Thursday July 14, 2011 @03:47PM (#2764718)
No you can't, yet. The statistical sample is much too small to determine whether Techstars is on par, higher or lower with Harvard comparatively to make this statement.
Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by wilschroter on Thursday July 14, 2011 @04:38PM (#2764982)
How many $100m startups did Harvard produce in its first 5 years of founding?
Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by ig1 on Thursday July 14, 2011 @05:10PM (#2765128)
We're not comparing HBS of 1908 to Techstars of 2011, we're comparing Techstars of 2006-2011 with HBS of 2006-2011.

Sure Techstars might be amazing in a hundred years time, but it's not exactly relavent for someone deciding what to do now.

Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by wilschroter on Thursday July 14, 2011 @10:10PM (#2766013)
I'm saying that Techstars has only had 5 years to refine itself. HBS has had over 100. I would think by that definition alone HBS should be churning out better results!
Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by pbhjpbhj on Thursday July 14, 2011 @10:45PM (#2766089)
>I would think by that definition alone HBS should be churning out better results!

Is HBS designed to produce tech startups though? HBS is probably closer to their desired results by virtue of "refinement" of it's aims and processes, yes. However unless those aims include "creating more tech startups" I don't see how their longevity is especially relevant.

Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by suprasanna on Thursday July 14, 2011 @10:47PM (#2766090)
totally agreed, you can't underestimate the importance of an alumni network and lessons from past years - advantages that make HBS v. TS a meaningless comparison in terms of success output.
Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by ig1 on Friday July 15, 2011 @07:05AM (#2766948)
Not if your trying to pick one over the other, we're not making some abstract theoretical comparison here about the fundamentals of the two programs.

If Harvard is better at producing startups than TS, regardless of the reason (alumni, experience), then Harvard would actually be a better choice than TS for someone looking to found a startup.

Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by feral on Thursday July 14, 2011 @10:53PM (#2766095)
The GP was pointing out that out of the small (relative to the number of college dropouts) group of Harvard MBA grads, there have been quite a few tech startups.

You are right that any such correlation doesn't imply causality - maybe the MBA and startup success were both caused by a prior drive.

But its an encouraging sign; that Apple and Microsoft were started by dropouts doesn't really change that.

Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by mnutt on Thursday July 14, 2011 @05:05PM (#2765102)
The guy who actually started Gilt Groupe, Kevin Ryan, got his MBA at INSEAD. Not that it changes your point much.
Re:Techstars or a Harvard MBA? by ig1 on Thursday July 14, 2011 @05:16PM (#2765161)
There were three cofounders at Gilt, the other two Alexandra Wilkis Wilson and Alexis Maybank were both Harvard MBAs (where they met).