If you truly value equity at $0, why accept it at all? Fwiw I've seen this experiment done with founding engineers, offer a sliding scale of salary and equity, in bounded ranges. 100% of people in that case (small sample) took some equity in exchange for a bit lower salary. Obviously they didn't actually value it at $0.
Also
Even if the "expected value" is high, how would you feel after spending years on what turns out to be a pretty low salary with no extra equity value, which is a very high probability event? Up to everyone to answer.
Those two are why I'm pricing such things at $0, unless there's a liquid market, simple capital structure and ordinary 10-Ks in EDGAR.
Whatever you call this sort of thing (predatory or otherwise), obviously it goes into your EV estimate/swag.
FWIW my answer to this stuff is never take a salary so low you would be unhappy if it tanks, which isn't the same thing as valuing equity at zero.
Understand that the "shares" that you get may end up being worth exactly $0, while the "shares" of the venture capital investor may end up being worth substantially > $0, because they sometimes are different things.
Just saying "oh yeah factor that in" doesn't help anyone who may not even know there could be a whole different class of "shares", as well as other corporate liabilities.
Relevant XKCD: https://xkcd.com/793/
By all means educate yourself, but this information has been out there for decades at this point.
I'm in no way advocating you saying "Oh, they gave me 1% on day 1, that means I'll get 5mm on a 500mm exit". You need to think about impacts of dilution and preference at minimum, but there's data on this.
And note I never claimed it would be accurate, the error bars are huge. But it's obviously more accurate than just setting it equal to zero. Which people really don't do, by observed preference.
Since we are in the weeds now, my actual advice on seed or earlier equity is mostly judge it as a measure of commitment and interest.
And at the moment the very top comment in this thread is about someone who got $100k, same as everyone, except the founders who somehow got out with 8 figures.
My point is to realize you're actually significantly disadvantaged. But i guess the youth has to do all the same mistakes over and over again, that's how the system goes forward. I should be cheering from the sidelines like most people do, it seems more fun :)
That's true, but it shouldn't lead to valuing equity at $0.
Before worrying about the impact of cap table structure you should also understand how and when they get that way - it really shouldn't be at the beginning (and if they won't show you some details then, walk away).
Compare this and the rest of your comp to other opportunities you have, and factor in how miserable it would make you if it fails (you aren't a rational actor).