Re:Scala isn’t complicated; it’s clever
by barrkel on Thursday July 14, 2011 @11:16AM
(#2763384)
I think you're getting caught up in the specific example he's chosen to illustrate his perspective. You're being too literal; perhaps even too "clever", in the way the article means it.
The frame, as I see it, for his post is the idea that Scala is too complicated. He sees things differently; that instead, "Scala is clever". The line out of Fight Club comes to mind: how's that working out for you - being clever?
The use of using technical Unicode characters for operators - technical characters that are unlikely to appear on any keyboard anywhere outside of very niche uses, e.g. APL-specific terminals - isn't terribly practical. But I imagine it gives someone somewhere a warm fuzzy feeling of correctness. This is the idea and meaning of cleverness that I think he's after.
This cleverness doesn't apply to things like e.g. Chinese characters for identifiers, because that does have extremely practical uses, not least because there are keyboard layouts and IMEs etc. in common use that permit it, and it may be culturally appropriate etc.
The frame, as I see it, for his post is the idea that Scala is too complicated. He sees things differently; that instead, "Scala is clever". The line out of Fight Club comes to mind: how's that working out for you - being clever?
The use of using technical Unicode characters for operators - technical characters that are unlikely to appear on any keyboard anywhere outside of very niche uses, e.g. APL-specific terminals - isn't terribly practical. But I imagine it gives someone somewhere a warm fuzzy feeling of correctness. This is the idea and meaning of cleverness that I think he's after.
This cleverness doesn't apply to things like e.g. Chinese characters for identifiers, because that does have extremely practical uses, not least because there are keyboard layouts and IMEs etc. in common use that permit it, and it may be culturally appropriate etc.