Re:Scientist finds early virus sequences that had been myste...
by abnry on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:39PM
(#27611997)
This suggests a Bayesian approach. If there is a lab leak, we'd expect a Chinese cover-up to be a more likely than a Chinese cover-up to a zoological origin. So if your priors are that the zoological and lab-leak origins are equally likely, the evidence of Chinese cover-up weighs in favor of the lab leak hypothesis.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Scientist finds early virus sequences that had been myste...
by phire on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @09:15PM
(#27612729)
That's only true if you assume China has perfect knowledge of the source of the leak from the very start in both scenarios.
In the zoological scenario, they wouldn't have any idea where it came from and might suspect it could be a lab leek simply based on the origin. It's very likely they would engage in cover-up behaviour anyway, just out of caution.
And then there are other reasons why they might decide to cover things up.
Ironically, a Chinese cover-up is absolutely useless evidence towards a lab leak hypothesis.
Re:Scientist finds early virus sequences that had been myste...
by 8note on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:58PM
(#27612607)
My priors disagree. I'd expect similar likelihood of a chinese coverup regardless of culpability. The embarrassment is too high in both situations
Re:Scientist finds early virus sequences that had been myste...
by sudosysgen on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @09:31PM
(#27612838)
China covered up SARS too and to a much greater extent, and we know that it was zoological. So my prior disagree with yours