Re:John McAfee found dead in Spanish jail after court approv...
by Stupulous on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:33PM
(#27611947)
I think very little history is about passing judgment on historical figures.
Re:John McAfee found dead in Spanish jail after court approv...
by CRConrad on Friday June 25, 2021 @06:21AM
(#27628978)
I think history is hardly about anything but passing judgment on historical figures.
Re:John McAfee found dead in Spanish jail after court approv...
by Stupulous on Friday June 25, 2021 @03:39PM
(#27635322)
I'm a determinist- I believe that if I were in an identical environment with an identical brain, I would behave identically. Reading social media, I see a lot of value judgments on people that rub me the wrong way- this person should be hated, that person was evil, etc. Extrapolating from my premise, I feel like those judgments apply to me and it stings a little.
Reading history, I encounter statements about what people did and about what motivated them to do it in a way that is aligned with my deterministic outlook. I never find myself bristling at a historical biography the way I do in, eg., this thread. The author might want me to judge someone, but they don't tell me to do so or even express directly that that is their belief.
I don't think a rule like, "you can't say someone is good/bad if you didn't know them," would result in a change to any history texts I've read, though I expect there are exceptions that I have not seen.
Re:John McAfee found dead in Spanish jail after court approv...
by CRConrad on Saturday June 26, 2021 @11:07AM
(#27642503)
Yeah, sorry, unclear: Not for the author to pass judgment, but the reader.
Re:John McAfee found dead in Spanish jail after court approv...
by antris on Thursday June 24, 2021 @05:42AM
(#27615561)
Historians do document public figures' personal lives all the time. It's a regular part of the research and not at all uncommon.
Re:John McAfee found dead in Spanish jail after court approv...
by 1123581321 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:26PM
(#27613172)
We would only need to rewrite the bad history books, which are, to be fair to you, an awful lot of them. :)
We're going to need to rewrite an awful lot of history if our standards for judging people are "knowing them and seeing them even once"