Re:Patent Trolling’s twin: Copyright trolling
by beervirus on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @05:40PM
(#27610805)
If you have a license to the photograph, why not just send proof of that to the troll and threaten them with Rule 11 sanctions if they sue you? I have to think anybody with a brain would just drop it at that point.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Patent Trolling’s twin: Copyright trolling
by jermaustin1 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @06:33PM
(#27611401)
Our “license” was the “photographer“ replying to an email saying it could be posted on our blog. It was just a cellphone photo of Robert Pattinson in nyc. Troll wouldn’t even let me remove the post. Eventually they just took the loss and let me kill the site.
Re:Patent Trolling’s twin: Copyright trolling
by beervirus on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:08PM
(#27612242)
What is a license except permission? They usually use fancy language, but that email might well have been plenty.
I’d let them sue me and seek attorneys fees.
Re:Patent Trolling’s twin: Copyright trolling
by halostatue on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @09:39PM
(#27612891)
So now you’ve gone from a claim for a few thousand to something where it’s going to cost you tens of thousands up front for court time _plus_ you have a chance of the judgement going against you despite the “permission” and now you’re on the hook for the original few thousand, _possibly_ the attorney fees of the troll, and _possibly_ some punitive judgement on top of it because you fought the “reasonable offer”.
My wife has published some books. We have a contract _licence_ written out for the art we _bought_ the use of for the book covers. The licence wouldn’t be a perfect defence if something happened like this, but it is something stronger than an email permission.
Re:Patent Trolling’s twin: Copyright trolling
by beervirus on Thursday June 24, 2021 @12:17AM
(#27613941)
Either there are facts not accurately recounted above, or the attorney did a shitty job. It’s as simple as that.
Re:Patent Trolling’s twin: Copyright trolling
by JoblessWonder on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @07:26PM
(#27611878)
If they are anything like the litigious people I've dealt with, they won't back down. It doesn't matter if you have a clear-cut path to victory through the courts... they will still proceed, usually hoping for a settlement or some sort of insurance coverage.
Unless you have an attorney on staff/retainer, it is a war of attrition and they always win. Better to stop the bleeding ASAP and just end it, even if that is a bitter pill to swallow.