Re:New network of European sleeper trains planned
by jodrellblank on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @08:27PM
(#27612391)
My original point was under "trains need more infrastructure than planes" to say "and less infrastructure than cars". You then said that trains need cars - which they don't. If you had mud paths, and wilderness between cities, and intercity train would be an improvement on that, so would a local metro. Cars wouldn't be an improvement - everyone getting a Honda Civic wouldn't be able to move on the too-small, too-muddy roads, it would be instant jam. So, trains don't need cars to add value.
I agree gravel roads at the end of a train journey with motorised vehicles would also add a lot of value.
Small-ish gravel roads for occasional supply vehicles to travel down isn't the original "road network" that I was arguing about efficiency of - small gravel roads in a world built around walking distances wouldn't be a world where everyone could run a Honda Civic and drive in two-way lanes of traffic. That is, by "cars" I didn't mean "motorised vehicles", but "everyone has a car and uses it for most journeys, and the road network to support that".
Re:New network of European sleeper trains planned
by CRConrad on Thursday June 24, 2021 @07:16PM
(#27625161)
> You then said that trains need cars - which they don't. If you had mud paths, and wilderness between cities, and intercity train would be an improvement on that
All you needed to say was: the "wild west".
Trains provably added a lot of value for decades without cars, because cars didn't even exist yet.
> "it's impossible because that would require forward planning" does show society in a bit of an unfavourable light, doesn't it?
Things break without warning. Or are you proposing we automatically replace our large appliances every few years even though they could probably last for 5 times longer? (even then you will still have random early failures). Not everything is worth repairing.