News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by maroonblazer on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @07:17PM (#27598573)
Agreed. In my experience with yoga and book clubs the females tend to outnumber - sometimes significantly - the males.

I'm sure there are others.

Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by munk-a on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @07:32PM (#27598748)
Even in hobbies that are usually seen as male dominated like comic books and video games - you'll find a significant number of women that are interested, though they may be quite defensive due to constantly being pursued.
Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by Dracophoenix on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @08:29PM (#27599225)
Then your back where you started with the ratio issue.
Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by void_mint on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @01:37AM (#27601114)
I think if you're thinking about a "ratio", you're kind of missing the point of these past few comments, which is to explicitly _not compete_, but instead just pursue happiness and attempt to make connections on the way.

If you're saying "But the ratio is off", your motives are probably incorrect about whatever "thing" you're thinking about doing.

Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by Dracophoenix on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @02:24AM (#27601398)
I followed the comments. I just don't see how not explicitly competing is consistent with pursuing happiness (polygamous relationships excluded). Even if one is not in a real or hypothetical competition with others for the exclusive reciprocation of one's interest and feelings, one is always competing with time and the opportunity costs that come with naive and fruitless decisions. The ratio is a major factor in that calculus. The massive amounts of time sifting through chaff is time taken from obtaining wheat. There's little gain to go any further. Happiness depends on an achievable end, not having hope strung out before you like a carrot on a stick. If you have no expectations then there's no point in doing anything. In these proposed meetup scenarios of common hobbies, we are assuming the best case that:

*one derives joy out of the endeavor itself

*one just so happens to find camaraderie with a group of strangers

*at least one of these strangers is of the sex that appeals to oneself

*this particular stranger is single

*this particular stranger is open to dating in this group

*this particular stranger finds one, among others, to be worth dating

*this particular stranger is receptive to one's advances

*this particular stranger chooses one ,out of a bevy of potential suitors, to be the one and only S.O. (for the time being)

Any of these circumstances can and do go wrong more often than not. Pretending that one can just wait and see and everything might turn out well is leaving everything to a self-deceiving lottery. In which case, why bother? What's the point? After all, someone could just as well fall out of the sky. The chances are about the same.

Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by void_mint on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:58AM (#27601974)
Your assertion is that "one derives joy out of the endeavor itself", in reference to the cultivation of a hobby, "can and does go wrong more often than not"?

I kinda stopped reading after this part. Best of luck in your search I guess.

Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by Dracophoenix on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:55AM (#27605978)
What assertion? One can cultivate a liking in a mutual hobby in a way that puts the other person off. For example, in political activism (which has been responsible for the creation and dissolution of many relationships) even if two people agree on same basic premises, that does not mean they share complementary motivations or standards in such a way that is conducive for one to want a relationship with the other person. And yes, as every human being has led a distinct life there will, more often than not, be differences in expectations and desires between two people and that likely will lead to something going wrong. That disproves the point that simply being in proximity to someone of the same hobby is necessarily an advantage.
Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by void_mint on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @12:41PM (#27606528)
You're again still focused about ratios and optimization and I'm again pointing out the original prompt was to cultivate hobbies without regard to ratios and optimization.

I'll butt out (as I unsuccessfully tried to do before). Enjoy your day!

Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by alisonkisk on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:36AM (#27605034)
you're missing the point. no matter how pure everyone's motives are, it's a mathematical fact that 7 men and 3 women aren't going to end up in heterosexual pairs.
Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by void_mint on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:39AM (#27605782)
That is a _rough_ way to live life, breaking down potential hobbies into “mathematical” ideas around probability to find a mate. I mean no disrespect, but that also sounds like a huge red flag in potential partners. “My only interests are optimizing the odds of finding a mate” is obviously not going to lead to an interesting and fulfilling life, both of which are usually important in and outside of relationships…
Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by KronisLV on Thursday June 24, 2021 @02:59AM (#27614686)
Perhaps that's why this is not always s good idea:

> I found my partner through a common interest and I'd suggest it as a preferable route for most folks looking.

(which then turned into a discussion of interest groups)

If you want to enjoy a hobby, enjoy it without the expectation of finding a mate. If you go in with that particular expectation, it might consume your enjoyment of the hobby. Plus, your odds aren't necessarily that much better, because of the reasons a poster above mentioned.

If you want to join a book club because you like books, do so. If you want to date someone, also do so (through apps or otherwise). If, however, you find someone who likes you at said book club, good for you! But please don't make everyone In the book club feel uncomfortable by making it obvious you're there to also look for a mate.

Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by munk-a on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @09:27PM (#27599664)
In the world there exist more women then men - I think it's reasonable to assume that homosexuality and asexuality are pretty gender independent factors, so there are more women looking for a relationship than men. It isn't a ratio issue - with apps it's my opinion that the experiences they provide are inherently toxic and drive away a lot of the potential customers - but this isn't an issue with society at large.
Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by Dracophoenix on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @10:37PM (#27600160)
Most of the, for lack of a better term, "extra" women of the world are widowers who outlived their husbands between their 60s and their 80s. Few of them are going be as springy as Madonna. I doubt the ones among them that are looking for a stable relationship are going to be compatible with 20-40 year olds looking for an energetic partner.

Areas where there are a surplus of contemporary women have language barriers and cultural differences that make a relationship more prone to dissolve. It's not impossible, but there are more problems than gains unless there's some quality that offsets those disadvantages (i.e. desperation to be married, partner has money or is of a favorable nationality, desire for a certain temperament in a partner, etc.). And this is on top of the usual issues and tradeoffs of a relationship. All things being equal, it's much easier to have a partner of a similar nationality or cultural understanding than going international.

While none of this changes your point about how "toxic" online dating is, let me remind you that the source of that "toxicity" is the people themselves. People are willing to take others for granted unless or until there's something in it for them not to so. This is also the case IRL in diplomacy, friendships, families, and all sorts of interpersonal relationships. The difference is that online dating brings a more brutally honest version of this dynamic into full view. No couching in euphemisms, no friendly facades and handshakes, and no "I regret to inform you...". Just an unspoken "show me what you've got". If you think this isn't practiced in society at large in some form or fashion, then it suggests you haven't looked closely enough.

Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by concordDance on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:23AM (#27601760)
> I think it's reasonable to assume that homosexuality and asexuality are pretty gender independent factors

Um, no. You should check these things rather than assume. Male homosexuality is much more common than female.

Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by the_only_law on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @10:46AM (#27605145)
Where are the women interested in purchasing and restoring 30 year old VAXstations ;)
Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by munk-a on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:13PM (#27608755)
I would find it pretty difficult to find a man interested in purchasing and restoring 30 year old VAXstations - that's just an extremely niche interest.
Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by the_only_law on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:17PM (#27608796)
Yeah I was just joking.
Re:Disintermediating friends: Online dating displaces other ... by prawn on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:53AM (#27601945)
Met my wife while volunteering (running a fundraising quiz night) for a youth breast cancer charity. Ratio there was pretty favourable.