News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California will pay off all past due rent by WalterBright on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @02:02PM (#27594950)
This is a giant slap in the face to every renter who scrimped and sacrificed to pay their rent.
Re:California will pay off all past due rent by threatofrain on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @02:49PM (#27595559)
And forgiving student loans is a slap in the face to any middle class family that had to scrimp and sacrifice for over a decade. Paying off somebody's loans is always a slap to somebody's face.
Re:California will pay off all past due rent by ryandrake on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @04:55PM (#27597090)
Uplifting someone else who needs it doesn’t slap my face. I paid off all my student loans myself, but I’m still for loan forgiveness and free, subsidized education. We’ve got to get past this zero-sum “he wins therefore I lose” mentality.
Re:California will pay off all past due rent by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @05:09PM (#27597253)
The (federal) government can print money. States can issue debt. There is no reason governments cannot give the same amount of cash to everyone, thereby not punishing those who played it safe.

The constant bailing out of only those who take risks is just socialization of risk and privatization of profit, I.e. corruption.

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by jude- on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @02:09AM (#27601317)
You aren't being punished if someone else's life circumstances improve.

Also, do you really think that the average American who has been saddled with the average amount of student loan debt would really be in a superior financial position if their debts were lifted tomorrow? The debt itself was preventing them from doing other economically productive things (like buying more goods and services, investing money, buying a house) that generate tax revenue. I wouldn't be surprised if forgiving all student debts turns out to be the economically favorable thing to do in the long run.

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by lotsofpulp on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:16AM (#27605492)
>You aren't being punished if someone else's life circumstances improve.

If it causes the currency to lose value, then it is a loss for everyone. Go ahead and help the average American, just do it by giving everyone the same amount of money.

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by jude- on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @12:20PM (#27606268)
Your currency losing value is not the same as someone else's life circumstances improving.

This program is about compensating landlords who were forced to provide housing for free, much like how hospitals get compensated to provide medical care to people who can't pay. I see no complaints about the latter, even though it's the same mechanism as the former.

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by dragonwriter on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @12:25PM (#27606333)
> This program is about compensating landlords who were forced to provide housing for free, much like how hospitals get compensated to provide medical care to people who can't pay. I see no complaints about the latter,

Un, that’s an uncompensated condition of Medicare participation, and there are lots of complaints from hospitals about the lack of compensation, and from small government types about the mandate and its affect on costs for those who can pay, and even the existence of “socialist” Medicare in the first place.

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by jude- on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:44PM (#27609131)
First, hospitals do get compensated some by both Medicare insurance and Medicaid; it's just not enough [1]. Second, a growing majority (63% as of 2020) of US adults want there to be at least a public option for healthcare [2].

Do you think hospitals should not be compensated for giving care to people who can't afford to pay?

[1] https://www.aha.org/system/files/2018-01/factsheet-hospital-...

[2] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/09/29/increasing-...

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by oluwie on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @04:05PM (#27596495)
So I'm okay with this b/c the government forced landlords not to evict people who couldn't pay. This is just the govt's way of paying it back.
Re:California will pay off all past due rent by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @05:09PM (#27597248)
The government should give everyone the same amount of cash then.
Re:California will pay off all past due rent by oluwie on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @05:43PM (#27597607)
Why? I really don't understand the logic for that.

You, personally, as someone who paid rent isn't owed anything by the government?

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by lotsofpulp on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @05:48PM (#27597656)
The logic is to prevent moral hazard caused by socializing losses and privatizing gains. By giving everyone the cash, people who made prudent decisions are not punished, and therefore are continued to be incentivized to make prudent decisions.

By rewarding only those who made risky decisions (whether or not they could have done otherwise), the system incentivizes that behavior. The effects of which can be seen in numerous events in history.

Note that I am all for redistribution of wealth if need be, but the mechanism must be fair. If the concern is why the government is spending excessively in comparison to tax receipts, then that is a different problem with the solution of “marginal income/sales taxes”.

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by jude- on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @02:14AM (#27601348)
> By giving everyone the cash, people who made prudent decisions are not punished

No one is being punished here. If you managed to pay rent, your pay-out was not having to deal with sudden mass homelessness from mass evictions, and all the downstream problems that would create for you.

The government forced landlords to house people who couldn't pay. This is about making the landlords whole, not renters.

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by curryst on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:27AM (#27605637)
It's still punishment; it's just negative punishment. Their punishment is having a positive stimulus (their money, their goods they sold to make rent, etc) removed, rather than having a negative stimulus added (positive punishment).

There's also all kinds of opportunity costs. That money could have been used for tons of things, or they could have reduced their tax rate.

It may still be that this is the most prudent course of action. There is likely to be massive fallout when the eviction moratoriums end, and this seems likely to solve that. Pretending that there is no harm to people who paid their rent is disingenuous though.

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by jude- on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @12:17PM (#27606232)
This isn't about renters, though. It's about compensating landlords who were forced to provide a service for free.

Like, are you upset that the government compensates hospitals for caring for people who aren't able to pay? If not, then you understand that this concept is not harmful, and there is no disingenuousness.

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by lotsofpulp on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @12:54PM (#27606726)
I think a better way would be for the government to provide the same healthcare to everyone, rather than restricting benefits to certain groups.
Re:California will pay off all past due rent by jude- on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @03:35PM (#27609013)
I'd love for that to happen, too. Why stop there -- why not also make it so everyone who wants one gets a place to live? Maybe do something like how Singapore manages housing? I'd love to have that as well.

But, we don't have either of these things right now, and the act of implementing them as a way to solve the immediate problem at hand -- compensating landlords for a service they were forced to provide as a means of staving off mass evictions once the moratorium expires -- is off the table, given the constraints of the pandemic relief funding that California was granted.

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by lotsofpulp on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @11:19AM (#27605530)
This person’s payout was having to move somewhere else and their kids losing their friends:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27596065

Re:California will pay off all past due rent by risk000 on Wednesday June 23, 2021 @02:16PM (#27607996)
This may be true, but I'd take a slap in the face if it meant another person had a place to sleep at night.

I can deal with slaps in the face. It's mostly an emotional feeling of being wronged. That's different than homelessness.