News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Comment moderators should focus more on hate speech than ... by wolverine876 on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @12:32PM (#27593792)
> Profanity (and blasphemy) is offensive to tons of people, arguably more than are offended by hate speech. But profanity is tolerated in many communities where hate speech is not.

That overlooks the degree of offense and threat. Some things are far more offensive and threatening than others. Clearly, hate speech is exceptionally offensive and threatening to many people.

Fuck. Shit. Asshole. My writing these words is rude, but has little impact. Even if I stuck them into my comments ('the fucking interface ...'), it would just be a little rude.

Hate speech can be a personal attack. Also, hate speech is often tied to power: If a powerful group uses hate speech against a vulnerable one, it can represent a serious threat: Humanity's history of the powerful abusing the vulnerable is long and terrible, and hate speech indicates, often intentionally, the willingness or intention to carry out such acts.

Re:Comment moderators should focus more on hate speech than ... by prepend on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @01:04PM (#27594207)
Yes, and the issue is the level of offense and threat. My curiosity is why a web site would think that it’s ok for people to be offended by “God dammit” but not by “[racial slur].”

I’m not really offended by profanity or blasphemy, but many are. So I don’t think it’s based on number of people offended.

I think I understand why hate speech is particularly dangerous, but it seems funny that other offensive speech is deemed acceptable. For example, HN allows profanity and blasphemy but not racial slurs (whether targeted or not).

Re:Comment moderators should focus more on hate speech than ... by wolverine876 on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @06:56PM (#27598380)
> I’m not really offended by profanity or blasphemy, but many are.

> it seems funny that other offensive speech is deemed acceptable. For example, HN allows profanity and blasphemy ...

I'm interested to know what your experiences are with this? I don't recall seeing a complaint about blasphemy in an Internet forum. However, I haven't quite yet read the entire Internet ...

What blasphemy is on HN? I could imagine statements that unknowingly violate a theological tenant - for example, to some using the word beginning G... for the monotheistic deity is blasphemous [edit: to some religions] (which, given the circumstances, I'll avoid). But I am not aware of any knowing blasphemy - there is so little religion here that it's not even an issue.

Hate speech directed at a religion would (or should) be outside the guidelines, but that's regardless of the blasphemy of it.

Re:Comment moderators should focus more on hate speech than ... by prepend on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @10:31PM (#27600127)
I’m not offended by blasphemy, but searching HN [0] reveals the following submissions that could offend people who are Catholic/Christian and don’t like blasphemy:

- “Jesus Christ, Use a Password Manager Already” - “ Revision 2020 Demoscene Event Live – Praise Jesus Christ” - “ So, just by looking at the box of pizza, you're going to judge that the pizza tastes bad? Jesus Christ man...”

[0] https://hn.algolia.com/?q=%22jesus+christ%22

Re:Comment moderators should focus more on hate speech than ... by wolverine876 on Tuesday June 22, 2021 @11:15PM (#27600379)
I see what you mean. I would guess that if you asked many people on HN, they wouldn't realize that it was offensive to anyone.