The problem is, everyone seems to equate noobs getting suckered by Musk with the 'crypto crowd'. I feel bad for them, but it's like saying /r/wallstreetbets are 'investors'.
P.S. - And where do they keep getting this 'fiat is going away' bull from? I honestly don't know anyone in crypto that thinks this? Yes, I see crap on youtube pumping stuff like this - is that now what the bar is? "I saw it on youtube" ?
I've seen several comments here on Hacker News that has this WTF-level of cryptoboosterism. Certainly anyone who seriously argues "but you forgot to account for the energy cost of nuclear carriers in propping up fiat currency" gives off the same vibes as "fiat is going to crash once we realize it's all funny money."
I honestly don't think I've seen anything like that here - but once the crypto threads get too long I stop reading cuz all the cranks come out.
But even if we stipulate that as true, is it fair to paint the whole crypto community with that brush? I see cranks in everything from cancer treatment to prepping to stock investing. Everyone seems to realize those fringes don't represent the majority views..So why is it when its crypto, the fringes suddenly represent the majority? It's a bit annoying, like we're all out there mortgaging our houses on this stuff...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27179397
> I find it frustrating that crypto-currencies are judged by their energy usage, meanwhile traditional fiat currencies are secured by massive banking industries, governments, and militaries. The total energy required to maintain a secure and stable fiat currency is likely orders of magnitude greater than that of Bitcoin today.
I originally had the quote as a strawman rendition (an exaggeration of the but-you-forgot-to-account-for-X arguments) of the enthusiasts trying to explain away Bitcoin's rapacious energy consumption, and like a week later, I actually saw someone try to specifically cite the energy cost of carriers.
Since then, virtually every thread on Bitcoin's energy consumption has had some people come out of the woodwork with that kind of defense, and I don't really have the mood to do the searching to establish just how common those views are.
But the other side of the coin is miners trying to reduce the energy consumption and use green sources. Again, everyone just wants to point at a vocal minority and call it good.
edit: I should probably point out the trend to move away from PoW to 'Staking' (PoS) solutions that are more energy efficient. The crypto community isn't ignoring energy usage issues.
Am I wrong?
...while I don't think that fiat currency will suddenly crash based on a eureka moment regarding the monetary policies by which the dollar is minted and lent (the latter).
I found this to be the central thesis:
> If anything, crypto is more likely to hurt the currencies of countries that are doing very poorly, such as Venezuela. Fiat currency won’t just go away, so over the long run crypto could actually boost the value of the dollar by stifling the rise of potential competitors.
...and the author is absolutely correct: much of the crypto crowd, whether or not they understand this, seems wont to ignore it.
I view blockchain tech - and even crypto assets - as a wonderful, peaceful, transformative technology in the long-term. But I also think that the need for calm analysis, thinking about much, much longer timeframes, is sorely needed in the 'crypto crowd' today.
> A second point, oft neglected in the crypto community, is that crypto prices won’t continue to go up forever at high rates. It doesn’t matter whether money supply deflation is built into a crypto system, or that new and valuable uses will be discovered each year.
Here I again I agree, but I do want to add something important:
New and valuable uses are very important right now. I work at NuCypher, and we are very proud of having deployed proxy re-encryption as an access management tool. But nobody is using it, for two reasons: 1) gas prices, 2) there are no other "new and valuable uses" which make access management worthwhile at the moment.
Whether or not you see a rich future for blockchain tech, I hope we can all agree that solid uses - especially those which advantage groups marginalized by yesterday's internet - are the real driver of the eventual equilibrium the author describes here.