News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reading Grossman's “Stalingrad” and ”Life and Fate” by watwut on Monday June 21, 2021 @04:13PM (#27583802)
As for first paragraph, the two are in no way in opposition. One can be both at the same time. And joining these units in the first place was one of survival tactic. Then you become part.

Also, literally all armies raped, some more then others. Rape is horrible, but it went on in wars a lot. Germans raped, some units really very much a lot. Russian soldiers raped. Both on the way to Germany and then a lot inside Germany. American soldiers raped (less then Germans and Russians). You are bringing it up and it is horrible, but it was not unique to these units at all.

Second, I have no idea how I would acted. I think I would die, because I am sickly in general. Which absolve me of moral choices I guess.No one of us knows how he would really act in such situation. Ressentment and hunger and genrally violence make people ok with things they are not normally.

Go even read that comic about Elan school someone posted on HN. Exact same dynamic in nutshel.

Third, the more I read about history, prisons, wars, genocides and cults and such, the more I became convinced of this. When you create brutal environment, people in it will become brutal gradually. Some more then others and yet others will be victims. But that is what happens every single time.

Re:Reading Grossman's “Stalingrad” and ”Life and Fate” by the_af on Monday June 21, 2021 @04:18PM (#27583868)
I'm sorry, I reject the idea that there's a set of brutal conditions that would have led me to rape, and murder even children in cold blood like the Trawniki did.

The scale and horror that Nazism and their willing lackeys inflicted upon the (modern) world is terrifying. No, under no set of conditions I would have behaved like the Trawniki. You say that every army raped, and this is true, but

> You are bringing it up and it is horrible, but it was not unique to these units at all.

I'm sorry, but again read what the Trawniki did and tell me it's of the same order of magnitude than what other armies "regularly" did. You can't, because it's not. Nazism enabled them, and these men, out of their own free will, went above and beyond the "call of duty", embraced it and rejoiced in this monstrous behavior. In many cases they weren't frontline units -- so their savagery upon civilians cannot be excused by saying "they were numbed and desperate by combat, and their prisoners suffered because of it" -- they conducted reprisals on civilians and served as guards in extermination camps, and were a key part of the Holocaust. They were reasonably well fed and clothed, and they chose to murder women and children. What's their excuse then?

I've read a lot about history, and know of men and women that perished because they refused to behave like savages, to know this is not the only possible course of action.

The Trawniki were really scum and there's no excuse for what they did.

Re:Reading Grossman's “Stalingrad” and ”Life and Fate” by watwut on Monday June 21, 2021 @04:43PM (#27584185)
When you askes "why" I thought it is about analyzing why. Now it seems to me that there is zero interest in "why".

> I'm sorry, but again read what the Trawniki did and tell me it's of the same order of magnitude than what other armies "regularly" did

Germans had units composed of criminals run by rapist. Like, literally guy convinced of that. It was largely uncontrolable body, not that anyone tried to controlled the rape away.

The history of armies and wars are people exactly like that. There were multiple genocides in history and it involves killing children each time. ISIS included. Rape included.

Re:Reading Grossman's “Stalingrad” and ”Life and Fate” by the_af on Monday June 21, 2021 @05:10PM (#27584532)
I never asked "why", so you must be confusing me with someone else from this thread. That said, "why" is an interesting question that can be explored, but "why" is not the same as "everyone would do this".

> The history of armies and wars are people exactly like that. There were multiple genocides in history and it involves killing children each time. ISIS included. Rape included.

In recent history very little resembles WWII in scale, savagery and murder. Things in Africa in more recent history, I guess, and the Armenian genocide that even Hitler paid attention to. But WWII's scale of bloodshed and ethnic cleansing is unmatched, as is the systematic, planned nature of said cleansing.

> There were multiple genocides in history and it involves killing children each time.

I'm not even sure what you're arguing here. Maybe that because killing of children happened before and after, that the Trawniki weren't monsters to be singled out and repudiate every time they are mentioned? I disagree. They were monsters, the worst of the worst. Notice I didn't claim the Trawniki invented ethnic cleansing or rape though. If you mention some other army that killed children, maybe hacked them to pieces using machetes during one of Africa's stomach churning conflicts, I'm ready to call them monsters too. Are you?