News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by _delirium on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @10:58PM (#2757598)
Seems to expose some different assumptions about the purpose of jail time. To me, it's purely protective: you put violent people in jail to physically incapacitate them until the threat of them causing more violence diminishes as they age. That's the reason most Scandinavian countries give sentences of under 10 years for most crimes, and under 20 years even for murder, because the risk of older people committing violent crimes is very low. So if your goal is to protect society from reoffense, the biggest win is to keep people locked up for their 20s; the 2nd-biggest is people in their 30s; and it gets increasingly pointless beyond that. In fact, giving supervised release instead of jailtime is often warranted, because keeping people tied to their communities / sources of employment is one of the best ways to prevent recidivism, while a few years in jail tends to turn people into hardened criminals (with fewer ties to the non-criminal world, and more ties to criminal gangs).

In this case, 18 years seems pretty clearly excessive from a protective point of view; it's not even clear any jail time at all is warranted, since some sort of probation with supervision of internet use would likely suffice to prevent him from reoffending.

My impression is that many people, especially in the U.S., have a notion of justice that's either more retributive or deterrent based, though. If retributive, that's a pure ethical disagreement. If deterrent, then we might have an empirical disagreement, about which lengths of sentences in fact deter crimes.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tptacek on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @12:10AM (#2757742)
By your logic here, there was little point in locking him up at all; he was already 45.

Interestingly, if you read the prosecution's sentencing memo, you see that protection is the core reasoning behind the long sentencing recommendation:

Barry Ardolf is a dangerous man. He uses his technical skills both to inflict harm and to avoid getting caught. Indeed, there is every reason to believe that the victims identified in this case are not his only victims. When Barry Ardolf is released from prison at the end of his term of commitment, he will do something like this again to someone else who has angered him, only this time he will be even more careful. The only way to prevent that is to incarcerate him for a very long time.

I'm absolutely inclined to agree with them. The prosecution earlier notes that even in this case, Ardolf's letter to the judge expresses no remorse for attempting to frame his neighbor for child pornography at his place of work, claiming instead that he had been "victimized" by the neighbor. Ardolf sounds criminally insane to me. I'm glad he was locked up before he did something far worse.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by Confusion on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:04AM (#2757834)
Solely looking at the protective aspect and ignoring an assessment of the chance of recidive, the logical conclusion is that a relatively low sentence is in place. However, I don't think the parent is advocating that only the protective aspect should be considered. After all, not even the Scandinavian countries do that.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tptacek on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:09AM (#2757846)
Everything after my first sentence is a later edit. I originally commented because the 20's and 30's rule of thumb he suggested didn't ring true to me. But when I read the sentencing memo, I was reminded of his point that protection is a key rational purpose of sentencing and moved to amend my comment.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by euroclydon on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @08:41AM (#2758748)
Are you against punishment?