News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by inoop on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @10:37PM (#2757565)
I'm not a legal expert so please correct me if I'm wrong, but afaik the US system essentially treats individual charges as individual crimes when it comes to sentencing. Note that a lot of other legal systems don't have such clear cut 'stacking' of sentences, because there is considerable overlap between the charges they correspond to.

Legal details aside, my question was more about whether it's morally right to sentence someone to eighteen years for the crimes described in the article?

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tsotha on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @11:29PM (#2757642)
I agree with you. 18 years is ridiculous for what the guy actually did.

I think part of the reason is they wanted to send a message. Not the one you'd think: "Don't terrorize your neighbors" or "Don't threaten politicians". The message is "You'd better take the plea bargain. Or else." Prosecutors don't have time to take every case to trial, so they threaten everybody with 100 little charges that add up to 150 years in jail. Then they offer you a deal, where you plead guilt to some subset and spend enough years in jail to satisfy the government.

It's grossly unfair. Nobody knows how many innocent people are wasting away in prison because they didn't want to risk spending the rest of their lives there.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by jacques_chester on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @12:04AM (#2757732)
Threat to kill and perversion of justice are extremely serious crimes. So too is being a menace to society. And so too is maliciously causing distress.

The sentence is up to the judge, within the limits set by the legislature. The prosecution can push for a plea bargain by quoting scary totals, but the judge decides whether the worst case comes about.

Of course, IANAL/TINLA etc.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by Terretta on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @12:21AM (#2757763)
> Threat to kill and perversion of justice are extremely serious crimes. So too is being a menace to society. And so too is maliciously causing distress.

Killer band and album names there.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by barrkel on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @12:44AM (#2757802)
Surely threats to kill should attract less punishment than actual killing, though.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by jacques_chester on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:45AM (#2757928)
In general they do; the exact terms vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. (IANAL, TINLA).
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tsotha on Monday July 18, 2011 @11:30PM (#2779495)
>The sentence is up to the judge, within the limits set by the legislature.

That's not necessarily true, or rather the legislature often sets minimum sentences. If you're brought up on enough charges you can end up in jail for life with no discretion on the part of the judge.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tsotha on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:15AM (#2757858)
With all those extremely serious crimes, how many people got hurt? And remember, if he'd taken the original deal he would have been out in two years.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by jacques_chester on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @02:03AM (#2757985)
> With all those extremely serious crimes, how many people got hurt?

Several families at least had their livelihoods directly undermined.

I can't speak to plea bargaining, it seems to be a largely American feature.

(IANAL, TINLA)

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by kahawe on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @07:33AM (#2758595)
That would mean: Just because you did not succeed in murdering someone, you are allowed to go free?
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tsotha on Friday July 15, 2011 @01:36AM (#2766399)
He didn't try to murder anyone. He made some threats, and he tried to get his neighbor in trouble with the law.

I'm not saying he should go free. But I am saying 18 years is incredibly harsh in light of the crime.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by lawnchair_larry on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:30AM (#2757881)
He did not threaten to kill. I disagree with your definition of extremely serious.

To me, this seems like harassment, worthy of a slap on the wrist. If he does it again, take away his computer privileges or something. But prison time? You have to be kidding me.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by jacques_chester on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:49AM (#2757937)
> He did not threaten to kill.

He was the author of an email threatening to kill the vice-president -- he is responsible for 'uttering' the words. In many jurisdictions that is the complete crime (strict liability).

Furthermore he aimed to pervert the course of justice by framing someone else.

Both these crimes are considered serious pretty much everywhere. Judges tend to look unflatteringly on perversion in particular.

(IANAL, TINLA).

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by orangecat on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:58AM (#2757969)
To me, this seems like harassment, worthy of a slap on the wrist.

Had his plan succeeded, the victim would be in prison for the rest of his life on the combination of kiddie porn and threatening the vice president. That's way beyond "harassment".

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by talaketu on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:49AM (#2757938)
From the article:

> The subject line of one e-mail read: “This is a terrorist threat! Take this seriously.” “I swear to God I’m going to kill you!,” part of the message to Biden said.

Not sure why you think he didn't threaten to kill. Seems he was found guilty.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by jacques_chester on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:55AM (#2757964)
Many jurisdictions have a great many crimes which are very similar, differing only in small details. These are written into law because nobody likes someone getting 'off on a technicality'.

For example, suppose I kill somebody. What will I be charged with?

Depending on the case, I might be up for murder, manslaughter or in some places "dangerous act leading to death". Each of these crimes has a different complexion and different punishments; the effect is that if I maliciously or carelessly hurt someone I could easily be hooked on one of them. Quite often the prosecution might charge me with all of them at once, then drop charges as the case unfolds.

However, for those crimes which make it to the "finish line", judges may be in a position to consider them separately or jointly. It varies wildly depending on jurisdiction. Supposing this was a jurisdiction where crimes must be sentenced in isolation, a high total is not impossible.

My gut feeling is that the judge has selected the higher end of potential jail terms because of the pattern of malice this individual has repeatedly displayed. One function of imprisonment is to remove the ability to cause more harm to society.

(IANAL, TINLA)

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by inoop on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @02:17AM (#2758010)
Thanks for the clarification!
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by jacques_chester on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @04:30AM (#2758276)
In a previous life I was a law student. If you're in a "code" jurisdiction, criminal law is about as straightforward as it gets. Pretty much the opposite end from torts.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by anseljh on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @11:23PM (#2757631)
Nope, there are often sentence enhancements when there are multiple crimes involved or if the defendant has prior convictions. Very common.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by smallblacksun on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @11:28PM (#2757640)
>Legal details aside, my question was more about whether it's morally right to sentence someone to eighteen years for the crimes described in the article?

Posting child porn and death threats? Yeah, that's worth 18 years.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by inoop on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @11:56PM (#2757714)
You're oversimplifying.

'Posting child porn' for example turns out to be 'posting a single picture of a pubescent girl having sex with two young boys'. Note that we have not seen the picture, so the girls' age can be anywhere between 10-17 (age range according to Wikipedia article on puberty). Note also that this picture was selected for shock value, and no other child pornography was reported found on the guys' computer.

The death threat was to a prominent politician who probably gets such emails on an hourly basis by cooks from all around the country.

So basically what you're saying is that eighteen years is appropriate punishment for being a 4chan troll?

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tptacek on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @12:05AM (#2757735)
In other words, "posting child porn" for example turns out to be "posting child porn". Full disclosure: I stopped reading here and downvoted you. I've also immediately revised my (previously more measured) take on all your previous comments.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by vacri on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:42AM (#2757916)
In the case of a 17-year-old, are you really suggesting that this person - who has the full right to have actual sex with whoever they choose (bar perhaps a guardian) pretty much all over the developed world - that a photo of this person is just as much 'child porn' as a 10-year-old?

The world is shades of grey, not the black and white you're demanding.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tptacek on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:43AM (#2757921)
Ardolf named this electronic image “Matt’s Kids.jpg.” See Govt. Tr. Ex. 5-2. This is an image of known child pornography identified as the “Sabban series,” where the children depicted have been identified. It has been confirmed that at the time the photographs were created, the children were minors. See Govt. Tr. Ex. 81. The “Sabban series” of child pornography was created by two individuals in Brazil, who sexually abused and photographed three children over a several-year period.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by vacri on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @02:03AM (#2757982)
That doesn't invalidate what's been said here. What you quote is not in the main article. And while most probably this series that you quote involved younger minors, it doesn't actually mention their age range - and 17 is still a 'minor'.

inoop was presenting an opinion based on the information in the main article and you stomped on him and effectively claimed that everything he's ever said is now suspect.

How many times has it happened that an article has used weasel words to paint an unflattering picture of someone, only for a more balanced view to come out later? inoop is asking people to look at the information that was presented rather than fire off a buzzword knee-jerk response.

If you have more information, then present it before judging, don't judge people on their opinions that may change with your secretly held information.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by lotharbot on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @02:21AM (#2758019)
He's quoting from http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2011/07/ardolf...

Page 8 describes the photo in detail. It's not a 17 year old, "barely a minor". It's a prepubescent girl and two prepubescent boys.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tptacek on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @02:09AM (#2757994)
I'm quoting the publicly available sentencing memo for this case.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by vacri on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @02:41AM (#2758069)
Apparently HN doesn't allow me the right of reply here to either lotharbot nor tptacek. Weird.

Anyway, the response is the same to both of you: I do not believe that either of you pore through every link in an article, reading all the way through before commenting. Particularly with court notes. No-one does. You're making a post-hoc defense.

If not reading the court notes linked in that article before commenting is worthy of having your credibility and history derided, then my bet is that pretty much every single commenter in this whole thread is guilty of this.

Also, lothar: your reference describes the picture of being of a prepubescent girl, which is different to the wired article which references a pubescent girl. From the context of inoop's comment, he's obviously going from the linked wired article and not the sub-linked court notes.

edit: sorry, swapped the last two paragraphs, 'if not...' was not meant to follow on from 'also...'

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by lotharbot on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @02:56AM (#2758096)
I can't speak for Thomas. For myself, I don't believe I've said anything that qualifies as deriding anyone's credibility or history (or trying to make a post-hoc defense for myself). I'm just trying to bring facts to light -- because a relevant issue was brought up, I took the time to pore through details I otherwise would not have.

In short, the issue brought up was that the sentence seems excessive given that "child porn" could mean a picture of 17 year olds. Having done the research, it's clear that the picture was of much younger children, and that the length of the sentence was due to several factors beyond the "child porn" issue. So the ancestor post to this raised a valid question, but was ultimately wrong on the relevant facts.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by AndyKelley on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @12:49AM (#2757814)
This is a bit rude. The grandparent's post is not stupid - he has a valid point.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tptacek on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:02AM (#2757828)
I respectfully disagree.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by inoop on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @12:49AM (#2757812)
See if you can get around to reading the last line though.
Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by Confusion on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @12:45AM (#2757805)
Grumpy today, are we? I would've thought someone like you would be able to go beyond "omfg, kiddie pr0n", but apparently possessing a single image that is legally child pornography (we'll probably never know what the actual contents were, so we can see if we agree with that legal judgment), that he may very well have downloaded from an a place like 4chan, where it was publicly available, is enough to morally justify sentencing someone for possession of child pornography?

I think every owner of a stash of pornographic material is guilty then.

Irregardless of whether you agree with the above argument, completely 'revising your opinion of me' for a single argument in a single case where you are conversing via a rather incomplete/miscommunication prone medium like this, seems rather like overreacting.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by tptacek on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @12:54AM (#2757817)
No, I'm not going to get past someone intentionally keeping and trafficking in child pornography. If anything, I'm perturbed that I've given you the impression that I'd be sanguine about it.

When I read someone suggesting that the state has sentenced someone abusively, then later find a comment where that same person says posting actual images of child pornography isn't a big deal --- or, as I found even further downthread, that physically molesting a child is something that warrants a stern conversation rather than police intervention --- I'm inclined to believe that person has very little to say about sentencing that I am going to find reasonable.

You are free to your own opinion about this case, and about 'inoop's comments.

Re:Wi-Fi–Hacking Neighbor From Hell Sentenced to 18 Years by lotharbot on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @01:47AM (#2757930)
> I think every owner of a stash of pornographic material is guilty then.

You think wrong. There are two crucial differences between the average porn owner and the vindictive neighbor.

The relevant laws, 18 U.S.C. § 1466A, 2252A, and others[0], repeatedly use the word "knowingly". The vindictive neighbor did in fact knowingly possess and distribute a visual depiction of a minor engaging in sexual activity. A person who has a large stash of porn that happens to include a pic of a 17 year old that they don't know about is legally safe.

In particular, the law allows a person in possession of fewer than 3 pieces of material to make an "affirmative defense"[1] if, upon discovering it, they either take reasonable steps to destroy the material or immediately report its existence to law enforcement. So the average owner of a stash of porn, upon discovering kiddie pics in his stash, can avoid all liability and culpability merely by destroying it or turning it over to the cops. The vindictive neighbor did neither.

I would argue both of these legal points are also moral points -- knowing you possess child pornography, and knowingly keeping it, is a whole different offense than accidentally possessing it and then destroying it or turning it over to the cops when you realize the situation.

EDIT: as to the broader point as to whether the sentence is justified, you can read the government's entire argument[2]. It describes the photo in detail on page 8; the individuals depicted are prepubescent, not "almost legal". It also describes the rest of the case; note that the sentence is not merely a child porn sentence, but includes identity theft, threats to the VP, violation of his initial release conditions, lying under oath, coaching witnesses, etc. The government explains the length of sentence starting on page 27.

[0] http://www.missingkids.com/missingkids/servlet/PageServlet?L...

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_defense

[2] http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2011/07/ardolf...