Re:Designing a better strcpy
by saagarjha on Saturday June 19, 2021 @09:31PM
(#27566219)
I've seen a lot of strlcpys, and of that I think I have seen maybe one place where the return value was used. I think if you asked people why they used strlcpy, 95+% would say "security" and then list out the characteristics my strxcpy has, rather than "I want snprintf-like behavior with a size_t return" which is what strlcpy is. I would not be surprised if most people got the time complexity of the function incorrect because of this.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
If the return value of strlcpy isn't used, the compiler can optimize the extra inefficiency away. (I don't know if any do, though.)
This is similar to how strlen(x)>0 calls get optimized to *x by clang and likely other compilers.