Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ...
by mikebike on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @04:35PM
(#2756435)
In this case, the monkey "borrowed" somebody else's camera, without permission, and took the picture in question. If I steal somebody's camera, and take photos with it, do I still own the copyright?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ...
by kevinpet on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @05:06PM
(#2756572)
Yes.
If I break into your apartment and write a poem using your pen, do I own the copyright?
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ...
by jrockway on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @05:43PM
(#2756737)
If I write code at work, do I own the copyright?
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ...
by kyleslattery on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @06:01PM
(#2756809)
No, because your contract most likely says that your employer owns everything you create at work.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ...
by eli on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @08:05PM
(#2757184)
You have a good point. Did the monkey get any bananas? It could be a Work for Hire situation.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ...
by joshu on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @02:26AM
(#2758024)
That is an offensive stereotype of monkeys.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ...
by serichsen on Wednesday July 13, 2011 @05:12AM
(#2758328)
Generally, yes, unless your work contract says something else. There are many companies who only have such work contracts, but there are counter examples.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ...
by Terretta on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @07:11PM
(#2757043)
Your downvotes suggest primate logic hard at work. You asked a question. Primates decided it must be rhetorical, and that you must mean you don't (or do), and that whichever you meant, your stance (though not voiced) must be disagreed with — downvote!
Bananas.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ...
by mtogo on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @08:16PM
(#2757220)
No, he's being downvoted because he was wrong.
If i break into someone's apartment and write a poem with their pen and paper, obviously i still own the copyright.
However, if i write code for an employer the contract almost certainly states that the employer owns my work (and in some (all?) states it's a Work for Hire). jrockway was purposefully making an argument that does not apply in the situation or make sense, and he is being downvoted for it.
I do not appriciate ad hominem attack against those that downvoted a trollish comment.
Re:Monkeys Don't Do Fair Use; News Agency Tells Techdirt To ...
by addandsubtract on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @04:40PM
(#2756454)
The question isn't whether you hold the copyright, it's if that somebody does.