> Is a person on the spectrum or with aspergers or with asthma more worthy of immediate death alone on an island compared to a "typical" person?
That is a nuanced question that I don't have an answer for. I would tend towards saying no though.
> The decision you find easy, rational and ethical, is only so if you have one of a few particular views of human value and you hold it strongly/dogmatically and in your supreme surety have no scruples in executing that position on actual people
I wrote my comment based on conventional societal views and under the assumption that all else equal, these are the rational choices.
I probably tend to align to societal views on this topic, but my comment was not really supposed to be a personal take.
I mean, it apparently is an easy choice since it's not your ass on the line
I've said that I tend to align with societal views, and my use of "rational" is in relation to what our society tends to value.
> I mean, it apparently is an easy choice since it's not your ass on the line
If you don't think it's an easy choice, I'd like to hear your reasoning for choosing a less intelligent/attractive/abled person given all else is equal in the desert island situation.
That's not an unexamined or implicit belief, and intellectual rigour is in this case only relevant when applying it.
Where is the is/ought fallacy in that reasoning?
You might have unexamined biases and assumptions about the nature of reality.
You might also be a little falling into the is/ought fallacy.
The decision you find easy, rational and ethical, is only so if you have one of a few particular views of human value and you hold it strongly/dogmatically and in your supreme surety have no scruples in executing that position on actual people.
Unexamined and implicit beliefs make life easier for normative people but they are not often intellectually rigorous.