News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coreutils Gotchas (2015) by uplime on Friday June 18, 2021 @05:31PM (#27555260)
> You seem to have a very narrow definition of "portable."

Can you explain how wanting to include more programs into the definition of portable is narrow?

> Can you link to the definition of the jargon term you appear to be using here?

The same definition I've always seen in every community discussing shell-scripting: if it's specified by the POSIX (Portable Operating System Interface) standard. POSIX does have a definition of `echo`. GNU echo does not conform to it by default, but can be configured to.

> Also, have you considered that some words have colloquial meanings too, and that it doesn't make sense to label them as "not correct"?

But it makes sense to label `echo` itself as not portable? The argument can be made that `GNU echo` is not portable (even though it can be with an environment variable), however that should be specified, instead of mentioning there are several implementations where it is non-standard.

Re:Coreutils Gotchas (2015) by burntsushi on Friday June 18, 2021 @06:13PM (#27555567)
You sound like a zealot to be honest. You misconstrued my post and gave a disingenuous response IMO. And you didn't answer my questions.