News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$1 of every $5 in US wallets in 2010 came from programs l... by gaius on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @12:51AM (#2753570)
The money would come from not bailing out the banks. Or rather, bailing them out via individual bank accounts. Power to the people!
Re:$1 of every $5 in US wallets in 2010 came from programs l... by jbooth on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @02:04AM (#2753723)
We turned a profit on bailing out the banks, actually. Or close to one, maybe lost a negligible amount when you weigh AIG against the profitable bailouts.

The issue with stimulus via tax cuts (which actually constituted 1/3 of the stimulus bill we did get, you don't hear about that much, because it undercuts the obama as devil-socialist narrative), is that, as pointed out above, you're primarily putting money back in the pockets of rich people. They'll invest it and maybe that will trickle down a little but it's nowhere near the multiplier effect for the economy that direct consumer spending gets you. Poorer people spend the money, that gets it bouncing around in the economy.

As a general ideological predisposition, tax cuts for the rich as a primary policy goal could theoretically make sense (although I'd suggest a hard look at the last 30 years first), but as fiscal stimulus for a down economy it just plain doesn't add up.

Re:$1 of every $5 in US wallets in 2010 came from programs l... by gaius on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @11:39AM (#2755112)
You are also shoring up the banks balance sheets, remember. As others have said, money invested isn't dead - it is actively lent to others.

Money spent on Stella, kebabs and fags doesn't really count.

Re:$1 of every $5 in US wallets in 2010 came from programs l... by jbooth on Tuesday July 12, 2011 @12:05PM (#2755242)
Poor people don't buy Stella, dude.

And you missed the point like 4x in this thread.. people weren't saying that funneling money to banks was unstimulative, they were saying that giving money to people who will consumer-spend it is more stimulative. This is pretty much accepted in the economic community.