Re:Survey shows people no longer believe working hard will l...
by dahart on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @03:53PM
(#27532742)
That’s what 20% social mobility means: that one in five actually move classes. The majority of immigrants do not change classes, just like the majority of Americans do not change classes. It’s still possible, it’s just not the average outcome.
> The article you linked in an opinion pieces of a single economist, who is critical of immigration.
What article? I linked to a section of Wikipedia, and that section alone has 9 different citations by as many authors.
> The good news is all level are getting higher year by year. The pie is growing for everybody.
Others in this thread have misunderstood my remarks as you have. The metric of moving from one class quintile to another during your lifetime is relative. It does not depend on standard of living at all. The pie can grow, and social mobility (as defined by changing class quintiles) can be stagnant, at the same time.
If human ability follows normal distribution, there is a hard physical limit of how many people can move up the ladder each year. It physically impossible for every one to be at the same highest level. The good news is all level are getting higher year by year. The pie is growing for everybody.