Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell
by xapata on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @04:03PM
(#27532847)
You'd not be able to label anything as non-fiction, unless it were from the mouth of Cthulu. No matter how dryly something is presented, the reader should still be skeptical.
Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell
by prepend on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:09PM
(#27553150)
I think it’s hard to be 100% accurate, but that doesn’t mean we should give up and purposely, or incompetently, include falseness when we’re trying to tell the truth.
Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell
by Talanes on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @10:30PM
(#27535636)
> Truth having layers of detail seems accurate to me. Outer layers conflicting with inner layers is foolish and means that the outer layer wasn’t true at all.
That just seems like how most teaching works. I.e. No one starts out learning physics as it works in any physical space, you start with a simplified fake version to start to understand concepts before you can start to handle greater complexity and approach greater truths.
Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell
by prepend on Friday June 18, 2021 @02:11PM
(#27553170)
There’s honest fake and dishonest fake.
Using simplified, fake versions to learn concepts makes perfect sense.
Teaching people that fake versions are actually true just to learn concepts is counterproductive. There’s no advantage to lying about training models and it’s not healthy, I think, to pretend I’m doing this for the good of my audience.
Fiction claiming to be non-fiction is annoying and should at least be labeled accurately.