News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell by elliekelly on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:51PM (#27530661)
I agree, Gladwell tells a great story and he’s absolutely entertaining to read. But I can’t quite wrap my head around how you began your comment by saying Gladwell doesn’t use rhetoric and end it by describing his writing as “stories dressed up as science (kinda)”. Is that not rhetoric?
Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell by jfoutz on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @01:12PM (#27530925)
"rhetoric to deceive"

He asks questions with many possible answers. He leads to one specific answer. He picks his favorite and dresses it up.

the difference would be, he knew for a fact that Bob murdered Alice. Saw it with his own eyes. He doesn't write books about how Bob couldn't possibly have killed Alice, it must have been Charlie.

He picks a favorite, says that's a good answer - rhetoric. I don't think he's leading people to an answer he believes to be wrong. He's not lying.

Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell by Ericson2314 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @01:55PM (#27531452)
The book review cites much concrete evidence --- done by actual scholars doing the tedious work of digging through "boring" archives --- undermining Gladwell's conclusions.

Yes, there are many conclusions to draw about these sorts of things, but getting facts wrong and omitting other information does not for a valid interpretation make.

He's a sophist storyteller.

Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell by groby_b on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @02:21PM (#27531745)
You don't get to claim an unproven alternate science just because it's a good story unless you're in the Fiction aisle. Gladwell would like to be in the non-fiction aisle, and he really utterly fails there.

He's "not lying" only in the sense that he spouts completely uninformed opinion. He knows that he does that, because it's not like he hasn't been told repeatedly. He continues anyways.

At that point, the line to flim-flam becomes tenuously thin.