News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell by lubujackson on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:33PM (#27530449)
It is hard to read this as a positive thing. You are basically describing a con-man (or more neutrally, a politician) who is skilled at convincing people of things through stories that are not factually accurate but feel accurate - "Truthiness" as Jon Stewart called it.

At best, it is a shortcut to convince groups of people of a point but it is the opposite of informative - people come away with bad information, not partial information and curiosity to learn more.

He is specifically disliked because he is selling the "take-aways" as knowledge when they are the opposite, then says he is just a storyteller - which is good and fine except he is marketed and digested as a layman's source of truth. Which is why we have people walking around thinking they can be a concert-grade pianist with 10,000 hours of practice even though the argument falls apart with the slightest analysis.

If Hacker News caters to curious "hacker mindset" types I think Gladwell is the opposite of curiosity: insights without discussion or understanding.

Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell by jfoutz on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:47PM (#27530616)
I guess, I like Gladwell for the same reasons you dislike him. He's popular and picked apart. I can read his books and be convinced, then find out about all of the ways he's wrong. Where did I screw up? What did I fall for?

Blink was probably the one that had the biggest impact on me. There are some gems there. It lead me to other thinking about thinking ideas. I learned a bit about quality of sources. I learned a bit about skinner boxes. Ironically I'm here, refreshing HN. So clearly I didn't learn that lesson particularly well.

Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell by s1artibartfast on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @02:18PM (#27531713)
Goodwin's law warning.

If you go into it with a critical eye and compare it to other sources, then you didn't fall for anything.

Reading mein kampf can be really insightful if you read it from a historical perspective and use the hueristics of skepticism. You can still dislike the original intent and think it is a missinformative work in general, but hold that the world would be better off without it.

Re:When pop history bombs: a response to Malcolm Gladwell by Ericson2314 on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @02:48PM (#27532043)
But "Mein Kampf" is an important primary source propaganda, whereas Gladwell's books are trash secondary sources, unless the object of research is "comforting false narratives of the early 21st century".

I don't think that's fair to "Mein Kampf" (!).