News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the Debt Ceiling Really Means by Locke1689 on Monday July 11, 2011 @04:15PM (#2752324)
You just have to look at what is actually being done, and not what is being said.

Yes, but what you said is:

Yes, that's the theory. But look around you. Is it working? No. We're doing way worse than those recessions where we instead responded by cutting taxes and actually living within our means. This theory is wrong.

This implies that the Keynesian theory of stimulus spending is wrong but you yourself admit that what is actually being done is not what is suggested by theory, it is some strange bastardized form. Actual Keynesian theory has been practiced in previous times and has succeeded relatively well. Even in this recession, the Scandinavian economic response is mostly Keynesian and they have weathered the recession very well.

Re:What the Debt Ceiling Really Means by jerf on Monday July 11, 2011 @04:50PM (#2752466)
"This implies that the Keynesian theory of stimulus spending is wrong"

Actually, we brought in the word "Keynesian" later. The original message I was replying strikes me as being based on the idea that it's just "spending", especially at the point where it claims that the Great Recession is from us "living within our means", which is a claim that just boggles my mind. The theory is that unqualified government spending is what pulls economies out of recessions; the reality is that isn't working, and also, it's not really Keynesianism. No contradictions.