News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by kazinator on Monday June 14, 2021 @04:04PM (#27507580)
Regardless of whether it is the case or not, Tour de France riders would not use wider tires to gain more grip around corners because ... wider tires do not add more grip.

You get a larger contact patch from a wider tire, but that patch has less pressure.

Grip (static friction) is coefficient of friction, times weight. The coefficient of friction is a constant which depends on the materials. Rubber on road is no exception.

Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by Retric on Monday June 14, 2021 @04:21PM (#27507776)
That’s the first order effects, however substances deform under pressure which is just one of many complexities involved. For car tires on dry pavement you get maximum grip from racing slicks. Unfortunately they need to swap in the rain.
Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by kazinator on Monday June 14, 2021 @04:30PM (#27507899)
First order effects are the only effects which matter in cycling. This isn't aerospace.

Racing slicks are a different material.

In Formula 1 racing, you go through multiple tires in one race.

In consumer driving, tires are expected to last 100,000 km or more.

There is even the practice, in racing, of using chemicals to attack the rubber to soften it.

Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by carl_dr on Monday June 14, 2021 @05:07PM (#27508303)
> In Formula 1 racing, you go through multiple tires in one race.

They could easily make a tyre which lasts the length of a race, but they mandate pit stops and two different tyre compounds to add interest - teams can use the mandatory pit stop to “undercut” or “overcut” competitors.

In fact, IIRC, for the 2005 season, changing tyres mid race for anything other than safety reasons was banned.

> In consumer driving, tires are expected to last 100,000 km or more.

This is much closer to 25,000-50,000km, and peaking at 70,000km. Source: https://www.pirelli.com/global/en-ww/road/how-many-kilometre...

Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by Retric on Monday June 14, 2021 @05:39PM (#27508652)
Using a different material is in effect irrelevant, they still get maximum grip from maximizing contact area because of how rough roads are. Ultra narrow tries need higher internal pressures, which limits how much the deform and thus reduces grip.

Also, F1 cars are going up to 246 mph and doing heavy acceleration and breaking throughout the races, which seriously heats up the tires. Normal road tires would actually die sooner under those conditions. Just read up on who long tires last when people are doing street racing, burnouts, etc.

Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by datameta on Monday June 14, 2021 @05:34PM (#27508590)
I might be missing something here but I believe slick tire compounds are geared toward longevity at the expense of lower grip. Unless you are referring to racing tires in general which are grippier than their street equivalents.
Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by Retric on Tuesday June 15, 2021 @05:18PM (#27521633)
Racing slicks are a type of flat tire designed for maximizing grip in dry conditions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racing_slick

Slick tyres are not suitable for use on common road vehicles, which must be able to operate in all weather conditions. They are used in auto racing where competitors can choose different tyres based on the weather conditions and can often change tyres during a race. Slick tyres provide far more traction than grooved tyres on dry roads, due to their greater contact area but typically have far less traction than grooved tyres under wet conditions. Wet roads severely diminish the traction because of aquaplaning due to water trapped between the tyre contact area and the road surface. Grooved tyres are designed to remove water from the contact area through the grooves, thereby maintaining traction even in wet conditions.

Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by datameta on Tuesday June 15, 2021 @05:30PM (#27521765)
Ah, so that terminology refers to the absence of tread. Thanks for the link.
[deleted]
Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by kazinator on Monday June 14, 2021 @04:48PM (#27508115)
Believe it or not, I have actually researched the "do wider tires grip more" topic (though not recently). I'm not simply extrapolating from high school physics class on friction. But, that's the executive summary.
Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by efraim on Monday June 14, 2021 @09:58PM (#27510513)
Rubber tires does not generate grip through simple static friction. They stick to the road in two different ways, adhesion and deformation. The adhesion is weak molecular forces that stick the rubber to the road like sticky tape, a larger area will have more adhesion. The deformation deforms the tire to follow the surface and dig into it. Because rubber is viscoelastic, the force is greater on the lagging side of a bumb when the tire is slipping.

The adhesion is greatest in the front of the contact patch where there is less slip and a wide tire has a wider but shorter contact patch, so it has more grip from adhesion.

If you keep the pressure in two tires the same, a wider tire will have the same contact patch area as a narrow tire since they will carry the same force and force is pressure multiplied with the area.

Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by wizzwizz4 on Monday June 14, 2021 @04:26PM (#27507850)
> The coefficient of friction is a constant which depends on the materials.

This is an approximation. It holds here, but it doesn't hold for (say) figure skates on road.

Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by kazinator on Monday June 14, 2021 @04:32PM (#27507920)
That is false; you might be thinking of figure skates on ice. Steel on road obeys coefficient of friction.

(I promise I will keep that in mind the next time I attach skates to a bicycle frame.)

Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by wizzwizz4 on Monday June 14, 2021 @06:19PM (#27509066)
Steel on road obeys the coefficient of friction… until it starts cutting into the road. Unless you're very light, that's going to happen if you're going an appreciable speed wearing figure skates and then try to stop.
Re:Myths in cycling: wider tires are slower by kazinator on Monday June 14, 2021 @07:01PM (#27509441)
Yes; anything cuts into anything else if you concentrate enough weight into enough of a small area, or there are other extreme factors involved like things melting.

E.g. A carbide bit milling a stainless steel object is clearly not following carbide-on-stainless coefficient of friction.