News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by JamesBarney on Monday June 14, 2021 @10:47AM (#27503204)
Just like you can't compare a gigabyte of cloud storage with 90% uptime to one with 99.9% uptime you can't really compare a kw/h of raw solar/wind to nuclear.

And once you install enough storage to make the 9's comparable, the solar/wind is quite a bit more expensive than the nuclear.

Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by bryanlarsen on Monday June 14, 2021 @10:51AM (#27503272)
Wrong. Solar + batteries has been built in the Mojave for $40/MWh, about a fifth the cost of nuclear.

https://www.energy-storage.news/news/developer-8minute-says-...

Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by JamesBarney on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:04AM (#27503424)
That just says they built a solar array with batteries for that price. It doesn't say anywhere that the uptime is comparable to traditional energy sources.
Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by koheripbal on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:31AM (#27529644)
This is not correct. They constructed that with small batteries - not nearly large enough to smooth out to 99.9% uptime levels.
Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by bryanlarsen on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @12:24PM (#27530322)
Nothing has 99.9% uptime, not even nuclear. That's a grid level property, not plant level.
Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by koheripbal on Thursday June 17, 2021 @07:53AM (#27538581)
I don't think it's useful to disagree about the number of 9s. The point is that nuclear is far more reliable than any other power source.

https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/nuclear-power-most-reliab...

https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=23112

Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by bryanlarsen on Thursday June 17, 2021 @08:58AM (#27539080)
The relevant metric is not reliability, it's reliability per dollar spent. And in that metric a grid built for 95% mix of renewable 5% natgas peaker with geographic diversity will trounce a nuclear.

Building nuclear in 2021 is like buying UltraSPARC in 2021. Sure, it's more reliable than a single PC, but a cluster of PC's is way cheaper and more reliable in aggregate.

Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by koheripbal on Friday June 18, 2021 @08:34AM (#27549639)
Your expectation that renewables will be able to handle 95% of the load without MASSIVE batteries and hence massive costs, is exactly the problem.

As an example, the large solar facility in Arizona produces 15% of the power in January, as it does in June. The batteries or overbuild needed to compensate for this tremendous imbalance in power production can only be offset with absolutely staggering scaled batteries.

...something that never seems to be modeled in the articles pushing renewables.

Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by Abimelex on Monday June 14, 2021 @02:29PM (#27506315)
Arguing uptime is a bit out of scope here, considering that especially in the US rolling blackouts are very common and the reason is basically the net, not the suppliers. On the contrary a decentralized PV grid would probably open opportunities for a lot of micro grids.
Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by koheripbal on Wednesday June 16, 2021 @11:30AM (#27529635)
This is an extremely hyperbolic comment, bordering on intentionally dishonest.

Rolling blackouts are incredibly abnormal, but would be extremely common with solar/wind based power.

A diversified power grid would still be subject to weather - which is common across the entire local grid.

Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by pfdietz on Monday June 14, 2021 @02:33PM (#27506378)
> And once you install enough storage to make the 9's comparable, the solar/wind is quite a bit more expensive than the nuclear.

This is not at all clear, especially going forward. The key is to shave off the last 10% or so with hydrogen and combined cycle, not batteries.

https://model.energy/ for actual model results

Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by Reason077 on Monday June 14, 2021 @10:50AM (#27503244)
You're right that a kW of nuclear can't be compared to a kW of solar, because the load factors will be very different.

But power stations are contracted/paid on the basis of the energy (ie MWh) they generate. And solar and wind can produce each MWh significantly cheaper than new-build nuclear can.

Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by throwaway210222 on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:14AM (#27503559)
> But power stations are contracted/paid on the basis of the energy (ie MWh) they generate.

But will they be continue to be paid by the solidified alumunium smelter and the gunged-up paper mill the week after the cloudy weather?

That said, in interesting innovation that may deal with dispatch-ratio limitations of renewable energy has become popular here in Africa for domestic lighting.

As you know, we have 'moved on' from electricity to candles and bush-fires for reasons relating to what is euphemistically called a skills-shortage.

Many of us are now using LED light bulbs with batteries in them. They charge when the power is available (Deo Volente) and offer ~4 hours light.

And we get to see the stars now.

Re:Why Nuclear Power, Not Renewables, Is the Path to Low-Car... by JamesBarney on Monday June 14, 2021 @11:08AM (#27503465)
It's true that most energy providers aren't really compensated well enough for uptime ( As seen in Texas this past winter). But that mispricing of current power doesn't solve any of the issues we'll need to solve to migrate to a lower carbon energy infrastructure.