News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Particle seen switching between matter and antimatter at ... by ben_w on Saturday June 12, 2021 @05:26PM (#27487556)
This reminds me of a question that popped into my mind earlier this year. Forewarning: I’m not a professional physicist.

If the Big Bang didn’t create an equal quantity of matter and antimatter, and given that antimatter is still being produced by various cosmological sources and at a lower rate for proton-antiproton pairs than for electron-positron pairs, would that imply that the universe has a non-zero net electric charge which is still changing over time?

And if so, what would a universe with a significant non-zero electric charge look like?

And if not, because Noether, could the combination of e.g. antiprotons and positrons into anti-neutrons turn out to be stable and one possible candidate for dark matter?

(Full blogpost: https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2021/02/09/baryon-asym...)

Re:Particle seen switching between matter and antimatter at ... by adrian_b on Saturday June 12, 2021 @06:50PM (#27488072)
As far as we know, during Big Bang, after the matter had cooled enough for heavier particles to decay but before cooling enough to allow the formation of nuclei and atoms, there were equal numbers of protons, neutrons and net electrons (i.e. electrons - positrons), so the electric charge of the universe was zero.

All the events that happened after that, e.g. the decay of a part of the neutrons into protons and electrons, the annihilation of positrons with electrons and various generations and annihilations of particle/anti-particle pairs, have not changed the total electric charge, so it has remained zero.

The electric forces are extremely strong and they ensure that matter is on average electrically neutral, so the only long-distance forces are magnetic and gravitational.

Any region with electric charge would generate strong electric fields with various obvious effects.

Re:Particle seen switching between matter and antimatter at ... by ben_w on Sunday June 13, 2021 @04:48AM (#27490930)
The observed bias of matter in favour of antimatter is a problem for the claim that particle-antiparticle pairs should have only ever been created or destroyed in matching pairs.

To rephrase my two questions about that observation:

1) What if the observed baryon asymmetry is an illusion because anti-neutrons are stable, unlike their mater counterparts? Would that explain anything?

2) If baryon asymmetry is real and not an illusion, what else should we expect to see?

> The electric forces are extremely strong and they ensure that matter is on average electrically neutral, so the only long-distance forces are magnetic and gravitational.

Which is why my question is specifically with regard to the observed baryon asymmetry as that might (in the case of question 2) mean the charges can’t be balanced.

> Any region with electric charge would generate strong electric fields with various obvious effects.

If the charge was distributed isotropically rather than in a limited region?