Re:The Crown Estate
by pjc50 on Saturday June 12, 2021 @06:29AM
(#27483388)
> peaceful transitions of power for 360 years
This is a myth we like to tell ourselves, like the destroyed colonial records.
360 years ago is 1661. Shouldn't you count from at least 1688 "Glorious Revolution", when the current monarchy of Dutch ancestry invaded?
Or, if you mean the UK, count from the Act of Union 1707, before which the UK did not exist as such?
Or, counting "peaceful", from the end of the suppression of the Stuart monarchy in 1746?
Or, counting "UK" again, the distinctly non-peaceful transition of power of part of the UK to Dublin in 1922? The consequent violence of which only ended in 1998?
(especially if you're going to try to count the US Jan 6 incident as "not peaceful transition of power"! You have to overlook a lot of UK electoral violence if that's your threshold)
The monarchy have largely managed to steer clear of this in the 20th century, although there was a near miss when Edward married a fascist spy and had to be forced out. Undoubtedly the influence of Prince Philip whose family were indeed exiled from Greece at gunpoint made a difference. The Queen has been very cautious.
Re:The Crown Estate
by dukeyukey on Saturday June 12, 2021 @08:46PM
(#27488753)
Compared to what went on on the Continent from around 1790 to 1950, the UK (and it's predecessors) has been an absolute beacon of stability and continued governance, even if there's been some issues.
This is a myth we like to tell ourselves, like the destroyed colonial records.
360 years ago is 1661. Shouldn't you count from at least 1688 "Glorious Revolution", when the current monarchy of Dutch ancestry invaded?
Or, if you mean the UK, count from the Act of Union 1707, before which the UK did not exist as such?
Or, counting "peaceful", from the end of the suppression of the Stuart monarchy in 1746?
Or, counting "UK" again, the distinctly non-peaceful transition of power of part of the UK to Dublin in 1922? The consequent violence of which only ended in 1998?
(especially if you're going to try to count the US Jan 6 incident as "not peaceful transition of power"! You have to overlook a lot of UK electoral violence if that's your threshold)
The monarchy have largely managed to steer clear of this in the 20th century, although there was a near miss when Edward married a fascist spy and had to be forced out. Undoubtedly the influence of Prince Philip whose family were indeed exiled from Greece at gunpoint made a difference. The Queen has been very cautious.